trim or remove?

Hello Long time listener first time caller I am hoping for opinions on how this tree should have been handled correctly If it is still viable and safe with the extent of the trim/logging What would be a “made whole” action anyone could suggest. Details: It’s a 120 year old black walnut...

I have this Oak in my front yard that I want to try to save while also preventing from collapsing on our house. I just want to say I have had 2 different certified Arborists come out, but neither of them emphasize whatsoever on the extent of the rot. Got quoted $2800 to trim 25%, and $4500 for...