Emerald Ash borer is in Minnesota

Arborist Forum

Help Support Arborist Forum:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.
Was goning to post this but bama beat me to it. This is the text to make it easier to read.

Philbert


ST. PAUL — Millions of Minnesota ash trees are at risk after the long-anticipated discovery of the destructive emerald ash borer in the state.

The infestation of the tree pest was discovered in a line of trees outside a row of St. Paul town homes, state agriculture officials said Thursday. State officials got a preliminary confirmation from a federal entomologist who viewed a digital picture. Final confirmation was expected Friday from a sample sent to Washington.

"It's pretty clear this is the emerald ash borer, and it's the first discovered in the state," said Minnesota Department of Agriculture spokesman Mike Schommer. "It's obviously bad news."

In response, the department plans to prohibit the movement of firewood, ash nursery stock, ash timber, or any other article that could spread the insect in Ramsey and Hennepin counties. Last month the state issued a quarantine for Houston County in southeastern Minnesota due to an infestation just across the border in Wisconsin.

Since the invasive beetle's accidental introduction into North America, it has killed millions of ash trees in 10 eastern states. With an estimated 900 million ash trees, Minnesota is seen as a prime target.

"We'd hoped this day would be delayed two years or more," said Bob Fitch, executive director of the Minnesota Nursery and Landscape Association. "But honestly, I'm not surprised that it's here."

Minnesota has the second-highest number of ash trees in the nation after Maine. Many of them were planted to replace trees lost to Dutch elm disease a generation ago, when streets in many neighborhoods lost their shade.

Chris Naselli, an arborist conducting a pruning estimate on the St. Paul property, noticed a suspicious grouping of woodpecker holes on a young ash tree — and tiny branches sprouting from its base. He peeled away some bark to discover rows of tunnels. Further inspection turned up five ash borer larvae and the shell of an adult. The tree's foliage was already thinning.

Across the street, homeowner Paul Johnston's ash tree was in even worse shape, its massive branches sprouting only a few dozen leaves and its bark in tatters.

"It's not going to get better," he said, noting the cost to remove the dead tree will run from $1,000 to $3,000.

The emerald ash borer — named for its metallic green color and taste for ash wood — typically will kill an adult tree within three to five years. The larvae will create tunnels just under the bark, disrupting the flow of nutrients.

There now are three trees confirmed to be infested, all in St. Paul's St. Anthony Park neighborhood. Many more in the area show symptoms of the beetle's presence, state officials said.

An official quarantine of Ramsey and Hennepin counties — preventing the transport of wood outside county lines — likely will come within the next day or two, said Mark Abrahamson, program coordinator of the state Department of Agriculture's ash borer program.

"The big thing now is just not to move it," Abrahamson said.

The beetle was first seen in Michigan in 2002. It is believed to have been shipped into Detroit in the 1990s aboard wooden cargo crates from Asia.

When asked whether Minnesota might consider clear-cutting ash trees around confirmed infestations, Geir Friisoe, director of the Agriculture Department's plant protection division, said, "There have been very few successful eradications."

But if an infestation were discovered in its initial stages, he said, the state "will likely pursue that option."

However, "There is (currently) no funding for removal," Friisoe said. "Everybody is aware of the budget situation in this state."

Rep. Alice Hausman, who represents St. Paul's south St. Anthony Park area, said she is calling on lawmakers to respond to the ash borer threat before the legislative session ends.
 
This sucks, I have many ash trees in a creek bottom. I love using ash for firewood, but not to this extent. I hate to see what will eventually take over after the creek bottom is void of ash. I'm already doing battle with that f'n buckthorn. That ####, (buckthorn) spreads faster than weeds and is almost impossible to kill too. If I'm not mistaken, buckthorn is another non-native species from over the pond that is infiltrating our woods and will grow in any kind of soil from sand to wetland. Hell, it even grows in the middle of pine tree stands where nothing else will grow at all.

It seems we just cant aviod Chinese anything these days. Bad enough we are foreced to buy their cheap-ass products, now we have to put up with thier Ash borer, and every spring and fall, my home and garage is plastered with the Asian beetles. GO HOME! :chainsaw:
 
Last edited:
"..."It's not going to get better," he said, noting the cost to remove the dead tree will run from $1,000 to $3,000...."

This guy must not know about CraigsList. There are hords of firewood cutters out there just waiting to PAY Mr. Homeowner to cut and cleanup those trees. [/sarcasm]
 
Sad to say, but will probably see it alot more but late summer. I wonder how/if it can be stopped or slowed? I have heard nothing cept don't move the wood from one location to the next, makes sense. First I thought the tree cutting folks may make a mint off this by fall, but I wonder if it will be legal to move the stuff. Also, ash is a great wood to burn, so I bet the firewood folks will be dropping/removing for free if possible? I'll bet someone in the state will be happy come end of year......$$$
 
Has quarantining actually slowed its progress or is it more like closing the barn doors AFTER the horses get out. Seems like after it is found in an area the neighboring counties should be in some sort of lockdown as well to close its doors BEFORE it spreads to them.

Maybe I'm just talking to the wind here but all the efforts to stop the spread seem to be reactive instead of more proactive.

Or is just that there isn't enough resources to actually combat it's spread instead of just placing a county in quarantine?
 
This sucks, I have many ash trees in a creek bottom. I love using ash for firewood, but not to this extent. I hate to see what will eventually take over after the creek bottom is void of ash. I'm already doing battle with that f'n buckthorn. That ####, (buckthorn) spreads faster than weeds and is almost impossible to kill too. If I'm not mistaken, buckthorn is another non-native species from over the pond that is infiltrating our woods and will grow in any kind of soil from sand to wetland. Hell, it even grows in the middle of pine tree stands where nothing else will grow at all.

It seems we just cant aviod Chinese anything these days. Bad enough we are foreced to buy their cheap-ass products, now we have to put up with thier Ash borer, and every spring and fall, my home and garage is plastered with the Asian beetles. GO HOME! :chainsaw:

A veteran of the "f'n buckthorn" wars here.The best way to kill it is to spray or paint a ring of Pathways II around the trunk.It will kill even the biggest of them in a week.I found it best to kill them all before cutting so that you can see if you missed any.Mowing really helps keep it down after that.
The best thing,well one of the best things, about moving to Kansas from MN is no Buckthorn and no Oak wilt.My forest is heathy and I can see 200 yards through the understory.
 
A veteran of the "f'n buckthorn" wars here.The best way to kill it is to spray or paint a ring of Pathways II around the trunk.It will kill even the biggest of them in a week.I found it best to kill them all before cutting so that you can see if you missed any.Mowing really helps keep it down after that.
The best thing,well one of the best things, about moving to Kansas from MN is no Buckthorn and no Oak wilt.My forest is heathy and I can see 200 yards through the understory.


Pathways II, I'll look into that, I'm not familiar with the product. I must kill 100's of trees/year. But the new seedlings sprout each spring and its hard to keep up with them alone. It doesnt help that my property borders another parcel with more mature buckthorn than a person can count. I have a bobcat which I use to uproot the bastards, but thats not the best way to deal with the problem. A bobcat isnt a very delicate machine to use in a woods since its hard to avoid running over other more desirable trees in the process. I have access to a brush cutter attachment for a bobcat, which is the a 6 foot wide brush cutting "nightmare" for anything under 2 inches in diameter. It works great, its just like mowing the grass when it comes to clearing brush. But again, it takes down everyting in its path.

I feel for anyone who has lost a woods full of ash trees. I was out back this morning walking through my ash stand trying to imagine what it may eventually look like someday. There are a few scattered oak and elm, but once the elm reach about 6 inches in diameter, they die off. The oak are hardy and very large, but only grow on the higher spots in the creek bottom.

How long does it take for a infected tree to die after the borer sets in?
 
A veteran of the "f'n buckthorn" wars here.The best way to kill it is to spray or paint a ring of Pathways II around the trunk.It will kill even the biggest of them in a week.I found it best to kill them all before cutting so that you can see if you missed any.Mowing really helps keep it down after that.
The best thing,well one of the best things, about moving to Kansas from MN is no Buckthorn and no Oak wilt.My forest is heathy and I can see 200 yards through the understory.

Uhhh we have Buckthorne in Cowley County. I cut a cord of it off a place a couple years ago. The guy wanted them out of his horse pasture because they were supposedly a nuisance to his horses. He was worried that the horses were going to pick up thorns. It turned out to be decent firewood and I was glad to have had it that winter.

I'm pretty sure it was Buckthorn. No camera then to take pictures for ID'ing the wood, but every image I could find of it on the net sure looked like it.
 
Has quarantining actually slowed its progress or is it more like closing the barn doors AFTER the horses get out. Seems like after it is found in an area the neighboring counties should be in some sort of lockdown as well to close its doors BEFORE it spreads to them.

Maybe I'm just talking to the wind here but all the efforts to stop the spread seem to be reactive instead of more proactive.

Or is just that there isn't enough resources to actually combat it's spread instead of just placing a county in quarantine?

Our quarantine lasted a year before it was realized it was too late.

The damn things had infected all the way around the state by the time they initiated the quarantine here. The brainiacs just hadn't figured things out fast enough and figured quarantine and cutting would contain things.
Nope. Already too late.

Another imported nightmare thanks to zero enforcement at our ports.

Stay safe!
Dingeryote
 
This is a BAD deal!!!!

I never realized how much Ash was around until I was edumacated by AS. ALL of our river bottom wood around here is Ash....were I cut...oak with ALOT of ash, and some poplar.

Sucks...that dang poplar is going to take over once the ash is gone!
 
Uhhh we have Buckthorne in Cowley County. I cut a cord of it off a place a couple years ago. The guy wanted them out of his horse pasture because they were supposedly a nuisance to his horses. He was worried that the horses were going to pick up thorns. It turned out to be decent firewood and I was glad to have had it that winter.

I'm pretty sure it was Buckthorn. No camera then to take pictures for ID'ing the wood, but every image I could find of it on the net sure looked like it.

I think there is a native Buckthorn down here, as I saw some in a yard down the street.You can tell if it is the invasive type if it greens up first and stays green after all of the other trees and shrubs have lost their leaves.It does make good firewood, and is very pretty for turning.The problem is that it grows in stands so thick that it stays a shrub(picture a field full of hedge).The berries have a laxative-like effect on the birds, so the seeds are everywhere.I started working in the woods with my dad clearing Prickly Ash, which was every bit as invasive as Buckthorn.In the same woods you will not find one Prickly Ash, or any other sapling for that matter.It's sad.I almost think we need to use Agent Orange and start over.
 
I think there is a native Buckthorn down here, as I saw some in a yard down the street.You can tell if it is the invasive type if it greens up first and stays green after all of the other trees and shrubs have lost their leaves.It does make good firewood, and is very pretty for turning.The problem is that it grows in stands so thick that it stays a shrub(picture a field full of hedge).The berries have a laxative-like effect on the birds, so the seeds are everywhere.I started working in the woods with my dad clearing Prickly Ash, which was every bit as invasive as Buckthorn.In the same woods you will not find one Prickly Ash, or any other sapling for that matter.It's sad.I almost think we need to use Agent Orange and start over.

Coog, The first time I laid eyes on it was the day it was cut. I dont know which variety it was or if it greened up early and stayed late or not. Across the fence it was growing about like you described in thick stands. The hedge trees didnt seem to mind them nor did the Tree of Heaven trees. But that was all there was in there.

Dingeryote, It does seem a shame to lose them simply because someone was asleep on their watch. From what I have read on it they don't start to show signs of infestation till they are nearly dead. By that tim,e a few years have passed and they have likely spread. Getting ahead of them with the quarantine or other more proactive efforts seems the only way to actually slow or stop them.

I wish you guys the best trying to combat it. But I reckon it is going to be like peeing on a campfire to put it out. It can be done, good aiming is important but one guy standing there isn't going to be able to do all of it.
 
Kswoods,

I have a couple survivors that are on the edge of my blueberry field.

I suspect that they have survived because of incidental treatment with pesticides from aerial spraying.

Couple of years ago I added provado(Imadaclorpid) to the early summer pesticide routine, and as a post harvest clean up as the stuff is systemic in my bushes and is pest predator friendly.

I just wish all my ash trees were on my fields edges.

The fricken bug is showing up in Minn. so it means it's made it's way to the Dakotas and south to Missouri....but just ain't been found yet.

Time to drop 'em and mill 'em if ya got 'em, and start a couple hundred for the grandkids to enjoy. There really is no stopping the bug untill it eats itself outta trees, or cost effective countermeasures are hatched.

Label restrictions on Admire, and Admire pro keep effective treatment out of unliscensed folks hands, but Bayer recently released a homeowner approved ground applied Imadaclorpid based pesticide... but it's gonna be pricy.

The Professional arborists seem to be making strides with Imadaclorpid injections but they are PRICEY!

Stay safe!
Dingeryote
 
its gets worse here on L I the EPA comes around to inspect your wood piles:cry: if you have 1 bad peace it all gos $$$$ tom trees
 
its gets worse here on L I the EPA comes around to inspect your wood piles:cry: if you have 1 bad peace it all gos $$$$ tom trees

It's too late for that to be effective. They are just collecting a random tax and bullying at this point.:bang:

Next time they come around, tell "Neal and Bob" to inspect the cribbing of the asian crap at the port before the EAB makes it to Wal-Marts everywhere..like they shoulda done 6 years ago.

Stay safe!
Dingeryote
 
its gets worse here on L I the EPA comes around to inspect your wood piles:cry: if you have 1 bad peace it all gos $$$$ tom trees

Sounds like legalized theivery, oh wait a beauracracity is involved. It IS legalized theivery at it finest. I bet it looks good on paper when they turn in their reports showing so much infested wood was 'properly disposed of at their convienence.
 
they come to all tree services and fire wood guys then they go after home owners i have seen the bug in wood four about 15 years now but it come down to $$$$$$$$$$ we make it they take it :dizzy: tom trees
 
Back
Top