Phillybonker
ArboristSite Lurker
I wish to kill a tree without cutting it down, is there any way to do this?
How do I kill a tree without cutting it down?
- Thread starter Phillybonker
- Start date
Help Support Arborist Forum:
Depends on the kind of tree....
Girdling it
Herbicide
Herbicide in girdle
Girdling it
Herbicide
Herbicide in girdle
a few copper nails hammered into it through the bark will do it
- Joined
- Nov 12, 2014
- Messages
- 3,582
- Reaction score
- 8,238
Salt the dripline
I’ve nailed hundreds of copper nails into tree installing lightning protection. It doesn’t kill the tree at all.
Girdling is simple & dependable, though not always quick
And why do you want to kill it?
Oh, and girdling kills the tree above the girdling cut. For many species, deciduous especially, the stump will retain the ability to send up fresh shoots. But if you're persistent these can be dealt with.
It's best to avoid chemical herbicides if possible, but sometimes the need is justified. Me, I go a long way to avoid chemicals.
It's best to avoid chemical herbicides if possible, but sometimes the need is justified. Me, I go a long way to avoid chemicals.
I go a few drops of Tordon to avoid doing the same work over and over again.
That is why I asked about species ... Some need a little extra "help" dying.
That is why I asked about species ... Some need a little extra "help" dying.
drive it in deeper and give it a year, they die
No...copper nails don't kill trees (unless you use enough not girdle the tree). Old wives tales that persists.
well
girdling
salt the dripline (apperently that works)
my dad tried but failed to kill a tree by drilling some holes into the base, and pouring salt into the base
tannerite if its not near the neighbors
girdling
salt the dripline (apperently that works)
my dad tried but failed to kill a tree by drilling some holes into the base, and pouring salt into the base
tannerite if its not near the neighbors
- Joined
- Nov 12, 2014
- Messages
- 3,582
- Reaction score
- 8,238
^^This^^?
CacaoBoy
ArboristSite Operative
What is the species? What is the size of the tree? Are there any other trees/plants/structures nearby? What, if any, restrictions does New Zealand have on the use of chemicals/herbicides or other methods of killing or the removal of trees of this type?
Newbie with his first post. I think he's just pulling everyone's leg to get a rise. Why would anyone want to kill a tree without cutting it down?
Oh wait - if you have an annoying tree from the neighbor's yard that you want trimmed or removed and he doesn't....
I suppose that's a good answer.
Not unlike a neighbor's annoying dog.
Fortunately I don't have one of those!
Oh wait - if you have an annoying tree from the neighbor's yard that you want trimmed or removed and he doesn't....
I suppose that's a good answer.
Not unlike a neighbor's annoying dog.
Fortunately I don't have one of those!
ehh, not anymore
Uncle, it's hard to know why someone might want to kill a tree without dropping it, but the possibilities are endless. The best reason I can think of offhand is to leave the dead snag for wildlife habitat. People often want me to remove a tree just because it's dead. But nature provides dead trees for wildlife, so I do my best to keep them in place unless they threaten structure, road, or drive.
Though probably not the OP's incentive, I girdled some ironwood trees just last week at my camp property so they'll die and dry standing. Within a year or two I can harvest standing dead, mostly dry & ready to burn wood that would hold more moisture if I dropped it in that predominantly wet river & lake country.
I've girdled thousands of trees.
Mostly doing woodland improvement. girdle the junk so the crop trees have more room to grow. It is often faster and safer than felling them. They do less damage coming down (usually fall apart in pieces), and like @old CB said, they are very beneficial for wildlife.
Mostly doing woodland improvement. girdle the junk so the crop trees have more room to grow. It is often faster and safer than felling them. They do less damage coming down (usually fall apart in pieces), and like @old CB said, they are very beneficial for wildlife.
Bango Skank
ArboristSite Operative
Swing in the dark; does this involve you getting more sun or less debris in your swimming pool? I hate those sort of arguments between neighbors.
For certain, providing wildlife habitat and halting growth to encourage other growth are legit reasons, but not a commonly offered service… and opening of this thread throws out a malicious vibe.
Hopefully I’m wrong!
For certain, providing wildlife habitat and halting growth to encourage other growth are legit reasons, but not a commonly offered service… and opening of this thread throws out a malicious vibe.
Hopefully I’m wrong!
