I shouldn't leave the impression its similar, its not. It has no ability to translocate through the zylem. It does penetrate bark, but it stays where you put it. The difference is very long residual, due to it being 23.4% AI. we use it at crawler stage and for bark beetles on high value trees, have had pretty good results. But it is cheaper, about $100 a quart, the fill is 24 oz per 100 for bark beetle and 12 oz for scale.
I am still interested. as you know, using a systemic in a tree already being attacked by bark beetles may not succeed. I performed an expensive experiment on that big pine by trying to combine it with pruning out all the infested trunk and limbs. I did miss some -- had to go back for two more faded limbs in the late fall ,and now there is another!
An insecticide that stays put like a carbamate (Sevin) is still considered a preventative, working by killing the adults as they bore into the tree. So, the compound you are talking about will penetrate to the phloem and kill adults or larvae in the tree? I found that Safari probably did this, but don't know for sure if the chemical got in first or the adults did in those 3 -6 in. diameter cedars (western red, incense, and Japanese (
Chamaecyparis). I did find that the adults' galleries were short, implying that the adults laid no eggs; also, the adults were dead and no larval mines were present.
View attachment 275803View attachment 275804View attachment 275806
Too bad the client was into "perfect" stuff; she probably had the trees ripped out anyway because they lost some limbs; I'll have to check and see if they are still there. I beluev they would have survived, unless enough pathogenic staining fungus was introduced -- and not all bark beetles neccessarily introduce it, such as red turpentine beetle (
Dendroctonus valens). I haven't gotten around to identifying the BB in these cedars, but it was very small, and may be the one that often kills arborvitae.
I have a lot of BB problems in my area, and an effective treatment that is reasonably priced is the "Holy Grail".