I've heard of the acid thing; even tried it with HCL...took a long time, but it worked. I don't know where a guy would get HFl, but you can get HCL at the hardware store (cleaning pool filters, etching stains from brick, etc.).Sulfuric acid for a battery might work, too. Be mighty careful...I've got faint scars on one arm from fooling around with nitric acid in high school.
But the thread parent said scored, which I took to mean a scratch, like from a busted ring...different than transferred aluminum from the piston. Maybe I should have asked...the aluminum "wipe" is extremely common...