Stihl vs Makita

Wesspur
Rugged made
Arborist Forum

Help Support Arborist Forum:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.
S

sdt008

New Member
Joined
Oct 13, 2008
Messages
2
Reaction score
0
Location
Ohio
Saw Suggestions

I am looking for some advise as to which saw to purchase. I moved from the city to the country 3 years ago. I cut, split and burn about 6 face cords per year. I purchased a "superstore" saw 3 years ago and it's inadequate for size/volume I need.

I am currently looking at a Stihl, Makita and Husky. All are mid 40 to mid 50 cc with an 18-20 inch bar

Cost is an issue
I welcome any input from the "field" and experts

Thanks for your time
Steven
 
Last edited:
Makita is made by Dolmar (a good thing). Do a search on Stihl 260, Husqvarna 346XP and Dolmar 5100. Those are the most highly regarded saws in the size you're considering. You'll find TONS of info.
 
Last edited:
A refurbed Makita 540 or 6401 from toolking.com might be just the ticket. They come in stock periodically, if you can play the waiting game. I got a 540 but have not had a chance to try it out though. Based on feedback in threads here, they are a good saw.

2Door
 
Best bang for your buck...

Pick up a 6401 on ebay, you can get a new or refurb for $300-$350. A lot more saw and Stihl or Husky have nothing that will touch it at anywhere near this cost.
 
Wet1 said:
Pick up a 6401 on ebay, you can get a new or refurb for $300-$350. A lot more saw and Stihl or Husky have nothing that will touch it at anywhere near this cost.
Click to expand...

Yeah, that's where it's at. Or the 5100. Bought both of mine brand new off ebay, the 5100 for a touch over $250, and the 6401 for $389. Both are great saws. Plus, with the 6401, you can upgrade it if you ever want to.
 
I like my firewood saws, a Husky 372XP and a Makita 6401 (Dolmar 6400 in blue). $299 minus $10 internet discount. What a bargain!
 
Arborist Rope Climbing Rope Swing for Tree(1/2in x 100ft) Logging Rope 48 Strands for Pull, Swing, Knot (Orange)
-7%
$37.99 ($0.38 / Foot) $40.99 ($0.41 / Foot)
Arborist Rope Climbing Rope Swing for Tree(1/2in x 100ft) Logging Rope 48 Strands for Pull, Swing, Knot (Orange) SDFJKLDI
ESTWING Fireside Friend Axe - 14" Wood Splitting Maul with Forged Steel Construction & Shock Reduction Grip - E3-FF4, Blue
-31%
$34.98 $50.48
ESTWING Fireside Friend Axe - 14" Wood Splitting Maul with Forged Steel Construction & Shock Reduction Grip - E3-FF4, Blue Amazon.com
PowerSmart Electric Log Splitter 6-Ton - Efficient Wood Splitter with 3500 Motor Speed, 15 Amp, Horizontal Full Beam Design and Steel Wedge for Firewood & Kindling Cutting
$329.99
PowerSmart Electric Log Splitter 6-Ton - Efficient Wood Splitter with 3500 Motor Speed, 15 Amp, Horizontal Full Beam Design and Steel Wedge for Firewood & Kindling Cutting Amerisun Inc
HeeJo Climbing, Rock Climbing, Safety seat belt for Rappelling Fire Rescuing Tree Climbing Gear
$66.99
HeeJo Climbing, Rock Climbing, Safety seat belt for Rappelling Fire Rescuing Tree Climbing Gear HeeJo
YARDMARIS Chainsaw Pants, Technical Chainsaw Trouser, Chainsaw Chaps, Tree Cutting Pant with Adjustable Suspenders
$229.99
YARDMARIS Chainsaw Pants, Technical Chainsaw Trouser, Chainsaw Chaps, Tree Cutting Pant with Adjustable Suspenders YARDMARIS
SaidiCo 56" Bungee Chainsaw Strap W/ 2" Ring & 225-4-1/4" Long Snap
$26.95
SaidiCo 56" Bungee Chainsaw Strap W/ 2" Ring & 225-4-1/4" Long Snap GoldenwestLawnmowers
FORESTER Chainsaw Protective Pants – Lightweight 360 Degree Class A Safety Protection for Forestry and Arborist (33-34) Black
$199.95
FORESTER Chainsaw Protective Pants – Lightweight 360 Degree Class A Safety Protection for Forestry and Arborist (33-34) Black MGP Supply
WEN Electric Log Splitter, 6.5-Ton Capacity with Portable Stand (56208)
-9%
$337.83 $369.99
WEN Electric Log Splitter, 6.5-Ton Capacity with Portable Stand (56208) Amazon.com
Pruning Manual Hand Saw // Hand Held or with Extension Manual Pole Saw for Tree Trimming // Fits All Extension Poles with Standard US Acme Thread // Tree Limb Hand Saw (Pole Sold Separately)
$25.97
Pruning Manual Hand Saw // Hand Held or with Extension Manual Pole Saw for Tree Trimming // Fits All Extension Poles with Standard US Acme Thread // Tree Limb Hand Saw (Pole Sold Separately) Extend-A-Reach
Weaver Leather WLC 160 Saddle with 2" Nylon Leg Straps, Medium, Brown/Red
$237.55
Weaver Leather WLC 160 Saddle with 2" Nylon Leg Straps, Medium, Brown/Red equipatron
Pfanner Hi-Vis Orange Chainsaw Pants - Medium
$469.99
Pfanner Hi-Vis Orange Chainsaw Pants - Medium Aardvark Trading
Brushless Electric Impact Wrench 1/2" 18V, Cordless Impact Wrench 1000Nm High-Torque Impact Driver with LED Work Light Powerful Wrench Tool for Car Tire Repair Wood Metal
$39.99
Brushless Electric Impact Wrench 1/2" 18V, Cordless Impact Wrench 1000Nm High-Torque Impact Driver with LED Work Light Powerful Wrench Tool for Car Tire Repair Wood Metal ZHAZHAMO
Weavor Arborist Speedline Kit
$275.00
Weavor Arborist Speedline Kit R&L Supply LLC
ESTWING Sure Split Wedge - 5-Pound Wood Splitting Tool with Forged Steel Construction & 1-7/8" Cutting Edge - E-5
$23.98
ESTWING Sure Split Wedge - 5-Pound Wood Splitting Tool with Forged Steel Construction & 1-7/8" Cutting Edge - E-5 Amazon.com
Weaver Arborist Bungee Chain Saw Strap
$17.79
Weaver Arborist Bungee Chain Saw Strap Amazon.com
ZELARMAN Chainsaw Chaps 8-layer Protective Apron Wrap Adjustable Chainsaw Pants/Chap for Loggers Forest Workers Class A
$79.99
ZELARMAN Chainsaw Chaps 8-layer Protective Apron Wrap Adjustable Chainsaw Pants/Chap for Loggers Forest Workers Class A QUALITY GARDEN & HAND TOOLS
Ttechouter Adjustable Thickness Climbing Harness Half Body Harnesses for Fire Rescuing Caving Rock Climbing Rappelling Tree Protect Waist Safety Belts
-26%
$36.99 $49.99
Ttechouter Adjustable Thickness Climbing Harness Half Body Harnesses for Fire Rescuing Caving Rock Climbing Rappelling Tree Protect Waist Safety Belts Techouter
GREENER Small Upgraded Log Splitter for Firewood - Wood Kindling Splitter, High Strength Steel with Sharpened Hardened Blade, Manual Kindling Splitter Cracker with Wedge for Fireplace and Fire Pits
$27.99
GREENER Small Upgraded Log Splitter for Firewood - Wood Kindling Splitter, High Strength Steel with Sharpened Hardened Blade, Manual Kindling Splitter Cracker with Wedge for Fireplace and Fire Pits GREENER STORE
Arborist Rigging Rope 1/2 in x 150 Ft Blue Bull Rope Polyester Braided Arborist Rope 1/2 inch 48 Strands 150 Feet for Various Outdoor Applications Construction Climbing Swing Sailing
-14%
$59.99 ($0.40 / Foot) $69.79 ($0.47 / Foot)
Arborist Rigging Rope 1/2 in x 150 Ft Blue Bull Rope Polyester Braided Arborist Rope 1/2 inch 48 Strands 150 Feet for Various Outdoor Applications Construction Climbing Swing Sailing Glfcai store
Double Braid Arborist Rope Orange(1/2 in x 150 ft) Arborist Rigging Polyester Rope - 48 Strand Rope Swing for Tree Bull Rope for Outdoor, Climbing, Swing, Sailing
$59.99 ($0.40 / Foot)
Double Braid Arborist Rope Orange(1/2 in x 150 ft) Arborist Rigging Polyester Rope - 48 Strand Rope Swing for Tree Bull Rope for Outdoor, Climbing, Swing, Sailing Cosirulnta Shop
Oregon Q90407 Chainsaw Sharpening and Guide Bar Maintenance Kit
$68.95
Oregon Q90407 Chainsaw Sharpening and Guide Bar Maintenance Kit Express Shipping ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Arborist Knots – Knot Cards for Tree Climbing – 14 Page Waterproof Pocket Knot Guide for Arborist Equipment Kit with 14 Tree Care Knots - Includes Wire Loop
$8.99
Arborist Knots – Knot Cards for Tree Climbing – 14 Page Waterproof Pocket Knot Guide for Arborist Equipment Kit with 14 Tree Care Knots - Includes Wire Loop ReferenceReady
SIP Protection Canopy W-AIR Hi-Vis Chainsaw Pants (Large)
$329.99
SIP Protection Canopy W-AIR Hi-Vis Chainsaw Pants (Large) Aardvark Trading
SOB Full Body Climbing Harness Can Be Inverted Thicken Widen Protect Waist Safety Harness Tree Work Rock Climbing Mountaineering Rescuing Work at Height
$103.98
SOB Full Body Climbing Harness Can Be Inverted Thicken Widen Protect Waist Safety Harness Tree Work Rock Climbing Mountaineering Rescuing Work at Height SOB-US
X XBEN Arborist Throw Line Kit with Slick Rope, Throw Weight, Reflective Storage Bag, Suit for Tree Cutting,Camping, Trimming, Hanging Swing, Forestry Tree Gear for Low and High Limb Throwing
-6%
$21.99 $23.38
X XBEN Arborist Throw Line Kit with Slick Rope, Throw Weight, Reflective Storage Bag, Suit for Tree Cutting,Camping, Trimming, Hanging Swing, Forestry Tree Gear for Low and High Limb Throwing X XBEN
FORESTER Arborist Throw Line Kit - Ultra Slick 100% Polyester Rope with Weighted Throw Bag | Forestry Tree Gear for Low and High Limb Throwing | 3/16 Inch Thick Rope (166' Rope with 15 Oz Throw Bag)
$23.95
FORESTER Arborist Throw Line Kit - Ultra Slick 100% Polyester Rope with Weighted Throw Bag | Forestry Tree Gear for Low and High Limb Throwing | 3/16 Inch Thick Rope (166' Rope with 15 Oz Throw Bag) MGP Supply
Delta Plus Standard Arborpants Chainsaw Chaps, Hi Viz Yellow
$129.96
Delta Plus Standard Arborpants Chainsaw Chaps, Hi Viz Yellow Amazon.com
VEVOR Double Braided Polyester Rope, 1/2 in x 120 ft, 48 Strands, 8000 LBS Breaking Strength Outdoor Rope, Arborist Rigging Rope for Rock Hiking Camping Swing Rappelling Rescue, Orange/Black
$29.99 ($0.25 / Foot)
VEVOR Double Braided Polyester Rope, 1/2 in x 120 ft, 48 Strands, 8000 LBS Breaking Strength Outdoor Rope, Arborist Rigging Rope for Rock Hiking Camping Swing Rappelling Rescue, Orange/Black Amazon.com
Extendable Pole Saw Branch Trimmer Pruner Head for Tree Trimming Pruning
-10%
$17.99 $19.99
Extendable Pole Saw Branch Trimmer Pruner Head for Tree Trimming Pruning FENGLICNSAOMV
Oregon Yukon Chainsaw Safety Protective Bib & Braces Trousers - Type A Protection, Dark Grey, Large
$194.26
Oregon Yukon Chainsaw Safety Protective Bib & Braces Trousers - Type A Protection, Dark Grey, Large Express Shipping ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
SOB Climbing Harness, Half Body Tree Climbing Harness Men,Thicken Widen Protect Waist Safety Harness for Arborist Harness,Working Rescuing at Height Safety Belt Harness
$64.99
SOB Climbing Harness, Half Body Tree Climbing Harness Men,Thicken Widen Protect Waist Safety Harness for Arborist Harness,Working Rescuing at Height Safety Belt Harness SOB-US
HOSKO 10FT Pole Saw for Tree Trimming, Long Extension Pruning Saw, Blade Tree Trimmer Pole, Manual Pole Cutter for, Yard Garden and Patios Trees Branches Cutting
$32.99
HOSKO 10FT Pole Saw for Tree Trimming, Long Extension Pruning Saw, Blade Tree Trimmer Pole, Manual Pole Cutter for, Yard Garden and Patios Trees Branches Cutting HOSKO
BILT HARD Log Splitter 6.5 Ton, Wood Splitter Electric Powered 15Amp, with Hydraulic Ram, Electric Firewood Splitting Machine, Horizontal
-9%
$309.99 $339.99
BILT HARD Log Splitter 6.5 Ton, Wood Splitter Electric Powered 15Amp, with Hydraulic Ram, Electric Firewood Splitting Machine, Horizontal Xi Run
EGO Power+ EP7500 31-Inch Extension Pole Attachment for Power Head PH1400 and Saw PSA1000
$69.00
EGO Power+ EP7500 31-Inch Extension Pole Attachment for Power Head PH1400 and Saw PSA1000 Amazon.com
Weaver Leather WLC 315 Saddle with 1" Heavy Duty Coated Webbing Leg Straps, Medium, Brown/Red
$215.05
Weaver Leather WLC 315 Saddle with 1" Heavy Duty Coated Webbing Leg Straps, Medium, Brown/Red equipatron
Husqvarna HUS TECH Pant S/28-30 X 32L
$269.00
Husqvarna HUS TECH Pant S/28-30 X 32L Tractors 2 Trimmers
Scalebeard Hand Pole Saws for Tree Trimming,Manual Tree Trimmer,Handheld use or with Extended Manual Pruning Saw for precision tree limb cutting-Pole Saw Attachment(Pole not included)
$19.99
Scalebeard Hand Pole Saws for Tree Trimming,Manual Tree Trimmer,Handheld use or with Extended Manual Pruning Saw for precision tree limb cutting-Pole Saw Attachment(Pole not included) Leermart
Wood Kindling Splitter - The Firewood Kindling Tool for Wood Stove Fireplace and Fire Pit
$39.99
Wood Kindling Splitter - The Firewood Kindling Tool for Wood Stove Fireplace and Fire Pit UniExtra
Fiskars Pole Saw Blade Replacement for Fiskars Pruning Saws and Tree Pruners, 15 Inch Saw Blade with Woodzig Chainsaw-Style Saw Tooth Design
-10%
$16.20 $17.99
Fiskars Pole Saw Blade Replacement for Fiskars Pruning Saws and Tree Pruners, 15 Inch Saw Blade with Woodzig Chainsaw-Style Saw Tooth Design Amazon.com
HandAcc Climbing belts, Thicken Professional Large Size Safety Seat Belts for Tree Climbing, Rescuing Work, Rappelling and Other Outdoor Adventure Activities
$53.99
HandAcc Climbing belts, Thicken Professional Large Size Safety Seat Belts for Tree Climbing, Rescuing Work, Rappelling and Other Outdoor Adventure Activities HandAcc.Store
BILT HARD Electric Log Splitter 6.5 Ton with Stand, Wood Splitter Electric Powered 15 Amp Motor with Hydraulic Ram, Firewood Splitting Machine, Horizontal
-6%
$329.99 $349.99
BILT HARD Electric Log Splitter 6.5 Ton with Stand, Wood Splitter Electric Powered 15 Amp Motor with Hydraulic Ram, Firewood Splitting Machine, Horizontal Xi Run
HeeJo Climbing, Safety Safe Seat Belt for Outdoor Tree Climbing, Outward Band Expanding Training Large Size,Climbing Gear
$65.99
HeeJo Climbing, Safety Safe Seat Belt for Outdoor Tree Climbing, Outward Band Expanding Training Large Size,Climbing Gear HeeJo
Firewood Log Splitter 45mm+32mm + 4 Handles (Square + Round + Hex Shank + Small Hex) Wood Log Splitter Easy Splitter Detachable Drill Bit Heavy Duty Electric Drills Screw Cone Driver Removable
$19.99 ($3.33 / Count)
Firewood Log Splitter 45mm+32mm + 4 Handles (Square + Round + Hex Shank + Small Hex) Wood Log Splitter Easy Splitter Detachable Drill Bit Heavy Duty Electric Drills Screw Cone Driver Removable JianShiMoQinDianZiShangWuYouXianGongSi
DOCA Pole Saw for Tree Trimming – Head Only (No Pole) - Extendable Tree Trimmer, Telescoping Extension Pole & GoSaw for Branches Under 2 Inches
$29.98
DOCA Pole Saw for Tree Trimming – Head Only (No Pole) - Extendable Tree Trimmer, Telescoping Extension Pole & GoSaw for Branches Under 2 Inches FourCity Brands
HandAcc Climbing belts, Thicken Professional Half Body Safety Belt Climbing Gear for Tree Climbing, Fire Rescue, Rappelling and Other Outdoor Adventure Activities
$35.99
HandAcc Climbing belts, Thicken Professional Half Body Safety Belt Climbing Gear for Tree Climbing, Fire Rescue, Rappelling and Other Outdoor Adventure Activities HandAcc.Store
X XBEN Thicken Climbing Harness, Protect Waist Safety Harness Gear, Wider Half Body Harness for Roofing Fire Rescuing Rock Climbing Rappelling Tree Climb
-11%
$35.56 $39.99
X XBEN Thicken Climbing Harness, Protect Waist Safety Harness Gear, Wider Half Body Harness for Roofing Fire Rescuing Rock Climbing Rappelling Tree Climb X XBEN
Oregon 50-52 (295435) Oregon A Type Yukon Protective Trousers Chainsaw Cut Prevention Work Gear Protective Trousers Black L Size
$172.50
Oregon 50-52 (295435) Oregon A Type Yukon Protective Trousers Chainsaw Cut Prevention Work Gear Protective Trousers Black L Size Express Shipping ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
OREGON 295397 Type C (All Round Yukon Chainsaw Protective Trouser, Black, Small
$225.16
OREGON 295397 Type C (All Round Yukon Chainsaw Protective Trouser, Black, Small Express Shipping ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Oregon 13" Curved Premium Japanese High-Carbon Steel Hand Saw, Rust Proof Forestry/Pruning/Cutting Tool, Curved Blade with Scabbard Safety Sheath (600136)
-14%
$35.53 $41.14
Oregon 13" Curved Premium Japanese High-Carbon Steel Hand Saw, Rust Proof Forestry/Pruning/Cutting Tool, Curved Blade with Scabbard Safety Sheath (600136) Amazon.com
Fiskars 8 lb. Splitting Maul - 36" Shock-Absorbing, Comfort Grip Handle - Rust Resistant Forged Steel Blade - Wood Splitter Maul for Hardwood - Split Wood for Campfires - Bushcraft Gear
-24%
$59.98 $78.99
Fiskars 8 lb. Splitting Maul - 36" Shock-Absorbing, Comfort Grip Handle - Rust Resistant Forged Steel Blade - Wood Splitter Maul for Hardwood - Split Wood for Campfires - Bushcraft Gear Amazon.com
Arborists' Certification Study Guide, 4th Edition
$144.53
Arborists' Certification Study Guide, 4th Edition Apex_media🍏
Arborist Rigging Rope Bull Rope Black (1/2 in x 150ft) Polyester Braided Arborist Rope 48 Strands for Tree Work Camping or Swinging…
-14%
$59.99 ($0.40 / Foot) $69.99 ($0.47 / Foot)
Arborist Rigging Rope Bull Rope Black (1/2 in x 150ft) Polyester Braided Arborist Rope 48 Strands for Tree Work Camping or Swinging… UIERTIO
lmalterna said:
A refurbed Makita 540 or 6401 from toolking.com might be just the ticket. They come in stock periodically, if you can play the waiting game. I got a 540 but have not had a chance to try it out though. Based on feedback in threads here, they are a good saw.

2Door
Click to expand...

The 540 is a nice saw, but if it came with that :censored: Vanguard chain, throw the chain in the trash and get a real chain.
 

Similar threads

cuttinstihl
288 vs 385/390 opinions?
2
Replies
22
Views
3K
davidwyby
davidwyby
B
Can anyone get new Stihl Arctic saws
2
Replies
34
Views
2K
Bill G
B
N
Oppama tachometer Pet 2000 DXR - pleasant surprise
Replies
0
Views
186
NHden
N
Mozzer
Stihl bar dilemma
Replies
17
Views
1K
Mozzer
Mozzer
U
I Bought The New Makita Mini Saw!
2
Replies
25
Views
5K
user 188535
U

Latest posts

Back
Top