Chinese stihl copies? NOT

Arborist Forum

Help Support Arborist Forum:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.

TimberMcPherson

Addicted to ArboristSite
. AS Supporting Member.
Joined
Mar 13, 2003
Messages
5,886
Reaction score
8,971
Location
New Zealand
A guy on a national ebay like website has been trying to sell these chinese made saws, saying that they come from the same factory as stihls or huskys. If these are clones of better known saws, which are they? I have been trying to figure them out! (although I suspect that they are just chinese made chainsaws) He did say he was getting some 104cc saws in soon.
 
Oh here are the specs he gives for this model

Model GL5200M SERIES
Displacement 52cc
Maximum power 2.2kw/3.0Hp
Rpm at maximum power 8000 rpm
Operating range 6,000-10,000 rpm
Fuel tank volume 0.55litre/18.6oz
Oil tank volume 0.26litre/8.8oz
Chain pitch .325,3/8inch
Chain gauge .050,.058,.063inch
Bar lengths 14-20 inch

Carburetor brand WALBRO
Saw chains brand OREGON

Air Injection Yes
Low Vibration Yes
Easy Off Filter Cover Yes
Adjustable Oiler Yes
 
Hmmm. I have no idea-the last Chinese chainsaw I viewed was a new knockoff of an old (geardrive era)monster.
 
Kinda makes you wonder when the name brand says "GOODLUCK" :D
 
Man that was fast, obviously they are just chinese made saws, not clones of there more reputable cousins. The guy selling them has been trying to pass them off as rebranded better saws, didnt think they looked like any that I could name

Thanks!
 
Mac, Since the Stihl and Huskies are made in Germany , Sweden Brazil , the U. S. A. and at times some components were Italian I suspect that the " same factory " bit was simply false. If they are chinese they probably are copies of western designs-that has been the way the chinese have been producing equipment for some time now.
 
Wonder how good these "Good Luck" Chinese chainsaws are? It would be fun to try one out just to see. My nephew has a Chinese made dirtbike out in my shed and it seems to work okay. It was really cheap too.

What was the price on these Chinese made saws?

www.atthecreation.com
 
Its very common for Chinese and Indian companies to buy designs for older equipment from big companies. There are a ton of chinese made 82 yz 250 powered ricshaws in India.
 
Originally posted by WoodTick007
These saws look very much like the Shindawia saws.
That is what I think too.
I dont trust asian saws or companies trying to sell em. I'll stick to stihl and husky saws with the official Stihl and Husqvarna badging.
 
I hate to make blanket pronouncements denigrating the quality of Chinese products. Certainly there are many intelligent and talented Chinese..The workmanship and quality control that I have observed on chinese machinery may be described as adequate and functional but the fit and finish is generally NOT to Western standards.--which tends to negatively effect longevity of service.
 
not shindaiwa

They may look similar (color) but they are definately not shindaiwas. Buy the way, OA, shindaiwa saws are every bit as good or better quality wise compared to husky or stihl. They are built to some of the tightest tolerances in the industry. I think of them as the honda of chainsaws. I have a husky 353 that wont run with my 488 and is a pound heavier. I have also ran a 346 a couple of times and it may be faster in small wood but with the bar buried in hardwood the 488 definately has more torque. I am of course talking stock. I have also never seen a saw the starts as easy as my 488.
 
Brent,

I also have the 488 and its a great saw.

My statement was not to place quality issues with the Shindawia Brand. Every piece of power equipment the make is "WorldClass" in every aspect. Their trimmers set the standards in the landscape/grasscutting industry and their backpack blower are right behind.

Take a close look at the photos of the Chineese made saws. They are a copy(in appearance) of the Shindawia 488.

Tick
 
well i got to say them saws look funny to me..but mabe they look that way cause the pics were taken with chinese lens..:)
i see no reason why an intelligent chinee couldnt be taught to make anything according to whatever specs the saw calls for.without going officially down the free interprise route.. the chinese greatest asset is milions and milions of people that want to work and will work ,for 1/100 of what we can work for.. then sell this thing in one of the countries like the us or canada..what u have is enormus profits and an gradual flo of the world wealth to these countries.. communism failed ,but the chinese communist didnt fail .. they continue to have an absolute power governing body,,that is now growing by leaps and bounds ,due to to difference in cost to produce products over there..
thats why when u take advantage of these cheap prices ,,u need to understand what u doing..u selling the future of u children..
but whos to say our younguns wont be better off having to figure thisun out..i also think they will come out on top,,after they have to experience hunger an struggle ,for a while..
just my ole opinion
 
Now, I never said that chinese products were junk, just that I dont trust them as much as the european and american ones.

Echo and Shindaiwa are both very good brands, I've never run a shindaiwa, but I have run an echo chainsaw and 2 SRM2100 trimmers, I liked what I ran. the echo is generally lightweight and powerful but quiet too. unlike Stihl trimmers, which I find to be loud heavy and annoying.

Not trying to anger the Stihl lovers here just stating I dont like Stihl trimmers.
 
I would tend to think the comment of these saws being made by or with bought technology and factory machinery of dis-continued saws is where its at. If TimberMcPherson's rpm specs are correct, its a dead give away they are old design equipment. What modern Stihl or Husky runs and operates at such slow speeds?

The saws would then be made on and with origianl factory equipment which is no longer in the original factory.
 
I can remember a time when people used to laugh and make fun of Japanese products: first little cheap "junk" toys, then motorcycles with "rice" for bearings, etc. but at great prices. Then look what happened!

The only thing that saved us was the Jap standard of living went way up and their products today are no cheaper than U.S. or Euro products. But there's no arguing about the quality of Jap cars the Koreans are making progress too.

Now it's the Chinese turn. As a bargain shopper I have some Chinese made stuff. By now who doesn't? It's a bit cruder and less well-finished with the paint slopped on. But that $59 drill press works good at a price that was too cheap to resist. But the day may well come when nearly EVERYTHING is made in China from the way things are going. I'm getting ready for the day when the el cheapo Chinese car hits the U.S. market.

And the day may well come when Stihls and Huskys are made in China too.

Downsize, outsource, find the cheapest supplier -- that's the name of the game. I've heard the HUGE Chinese demand for steel and other raw materials are really driving world prices thru the roof. Their quickly rising demand for oil too which we will all suffer from at the pump in years to come.

That's why I'd like to try one of these GOOD LUCK saws. Just to find out how well one would hold up -- or blow up.

But when you think about what this is doing to our domestic industries you gotta wonder who the brain was that opened the U.S. market to Chinese goods. But the same was true of Japan and other foreign industry...look what Stihl did to Homelite.

My 2 cents.

www.atthecreation.com
 

Latest posts

Back
Top