Hemlock

Arborist Forum

Help Support Arborist Forum:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.

rarefish383

Addicted to ArboristSite
. AS Supporting Member.
Joined
Nov 2, 2009
Messages
9,678
Reaction score
33,662
Location
MD
I got volunteered to take down a couple big hemlocks for my father In Law tomorrow. They're about 50' tall and 20" in diameter, maybe bigger. I really haven't payed any attention to them in years. Should I keep the logs? My Alaskan should be here sometime next week. My Father In Law has a very nice wood shop. If nothing else I can get some practice in milling some smaller logs, Joe.
 
I wouldn't recommend Hemlock for structural for two reasons: It's hard as nails compared to other softwoods while not being significantly stronger, and it rots quite easily. It makes awesome flooring, stair treads, trim/molding stock, doors, and much more for interior work. But it isn't ideal for exterior. I'd keep the logs though, especially if there aren't many big knots.
 
Brad, maybe that sub cold up there grows a different tree. The hemlocks here are used for rafters, joists, beam and siding. It is very rot resistant & doesn't twist or warp much when drying.

Joe, I'd mill them up!

RD
 
Yes, Western Hemlock is a different species from what you guys see back East, but the wood is almost indistinguishable.

Rot resistant compared to what though? If I were to compare it to Birch, Hemlock would be excellent. However compared to Cedar, Douglas Fir, and for that matter even Lodgepole Pine, it doesn't hold up nearly so well if it is sitting in a moist environment. I agree that it makes a superb interior structural wood due to its hardness and strength, and is also very good for other uses if properly treated and sealed with paint or stain. But if I were to drop Hemlock, Doug Fir, Lodgepole, and Cedar trees side by side in the bush and left them to rot, the Hemlock would be rotten beyond usability within just a few years, while the Cedar would still be there three or four generations from now and still probably millable. I've even cut into Douglas Fir logs I've found laying in the bush that were left there back in the '40s-'50s when the area was first logged, and while the outer few inches are usually rotten, the inside is still as sound as the day it fell. I'm not saying Hemlock is a bad wood - I love the stuff - I was just stating that it isn't ideal for unprotected use in moist environments.
 
Where I am, New York, the only softwoods I put before it in durability are cedar and larch (tamarack).

Yes, Western Hemlock is a different species from what you guys see back East, but the wood is almost indistinguishable.

Rot resistant compared to what though? If I were to compare it to Birch, Hemlock would be excellent. However compared to Cedar, Douglas Fir, and for that matter even Lodgepole Pine, it doesn't hold up nearly so well if it is sitting in a moist environment. I agree that it makes a superb interior structural wood due to its hardness and strength, and is also very good for other uses if properly treated and sealed with paint or stain. But if I were to drop Hemlock, Doug Fir, Lodgepole, and Cedar trees side by side in the bush and left them to rot, the Hemlock would be rotten beyond usability within just a few years, while the Cedar would still be there three or four generations from now and still probably millable. I've even cut into Douglas Fir logs I've found laying in the bush that were left there back in the '40s-'50s when the area was first logged, and while the outer few inches are usually rotten, the inside is still as sound as the day it fell. I'm not saying Hemlock is a bad wood - I love the stuff - I was just stating that it isn't ideal for unprotected use in moist environments.
 
a good wood to practice on, rots quick as others have said
make some shelves for the basement or garage, ramps for easy oil changes
maybe a live edge bench to sit on to put your work boots on
worst case ...a self consuming compost bin
go for it and get your mill tested
 
a good wood to practice on, rots quick as others have said
make some shelves for the basement or garage, ramps for easy oil changes
maybe a live edge bench to sit on to put your work boots on
worst case ...a self consuming compost bin
go for it and get your mill tested

I built one of those out of some half rotted white pine that I milled up! Good idea.
 
Thanks for all of the input. I went down to the inlaws and they changed their mind about taking them down for the time being. Just as well, I must be getting old, in my minds eye they were big trees. When I got there they turned out to be only about 25 feet tall and maybe 10-12 inches in diameter, Joe.
 
Took down a bunch like that at my inlaws this summer. Ended up with 54@2x4, 6@2x6 and enough slabs to fill in the wet spots in the new bush trail.
 

Latest posts

Back
Top