How many of you do root crown/buttress checks

Arborist Forum

Help Support Arborist Forum:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.

P_woozel

ArboristSite Guru
Joined
Oct 19, 2004
Messages
503
Reaction score
1
Location
west coast
when using a stem for a heavy rigging removal how many of you check the condition of the buttress roots and root crown for obvious signs of problems and when found continue a further exam before loading that stem hard (800#+) ?:Eye:
 
Every time. Or it's a serious senior moment. Like we were talking on the other thread, the tree's holding all the best laid plans of mice and men.
 
I certainly didn't mean that in depth! If warranted, I guess. But you can figure most problems out pretty quickly, I would say. For example, if a road was repaved and the sidewalks as well, one should already be on high alert when thinking about the stability of the trees.
 
I don't go digging around the trunk flare, however I do look at the surrounding soil to look for fractures, or signs of prior excavation damage (or in one case blasting damage :eek: ) and adjust my rigging procedures accordingly.
 
Nope, they were doing an addition to a house which was built on ROCK. How the heck they got blasting permits was beyond my comprehension. I got called in to remove a cottonwood which was still standing after the blasting had commenced. Somebody is going to have to explain to me one day exactly why people feel it is better to build the structure and THEN take down the big, dangerous tree. :rolleyes:
 
In reality, you should give the tree at least a cursory look-over whether you're using it for rigging, climbing it, or just notch'n'dropping it.
 
Rubber mallet is a great tool. I've had to dig more than that pic showed, but rarely. Signs of decay get easier to spot, the more experience you get looking.

Buttress inspection critical for PHC too, see Assessment below handout for MG class, with shameless plug at the bottom.

Master Gardeners’ Tree Care Guidelines

TREES are the keystone life form in the urban ecosystem. Air and water quality suffer irreparable harm if an adequate tree cover is not maintained. For details on the value of urban trees, see http://www.americanforests.org/downloads/rea/AF_Charlotte.pdf. Songbirds and other wildlife would have nowhere to live, and gardening would barely be possible without healthy soil built and held together by trees.

Planting: Find the Flare!
The trunk flare is the bottom of the stem, where it spreads out to form the root system. Whether they are container-grown or balled-and-burlapped, the majority of nursery-grown plants have the trunk flare buried. The flare must be found, and any circling roots should be straightened. Plant the tree so the flare is at or just above grade, in a wide bed amended so it contains adequate levels of organic matter and oxygen.

Assessment: Find the Flare!
When diagnosing tree problems, the first place to look is the trunk flare. Older trees typically have some diseased areas between the buttresses; this is treatable and not a great concern unless decay is extensive. Most of the problems in newly planted trees are a result of girdling roots, deep planting and overmulching. Small girdling roots should be straightened or cut, because large ones can become hazardous defects.

Pruning: Find the Collar!
The branch collar is a raised ring of tissue at the base of the branch. On some species it is easier to see than on others. Cuts should be made just outside of the collar. Sometimes heading cuts (cuts to nodes where there is no side branch) must be made on trees and shrubs. Heading cuts between nodes, on wood too big to seal and dependably regrow, are called Topping. Topping is a tree sin and often destroys perfectly innocent trees.

ISA Certified Arborists have three years’ experience and have passed a test showing basic knowledge of tree care. Together with references and proof of insurance, this credential is a good indicator of someone that can be trusted with the care of trees.
ISA Board Certified Master Arborists have a minimum of 7 years experience as an ISA Certified Arborist or its equivalent. They must pass a computer-based exam that intensively covers all aspects of arboriculture. These individuals have advanced levels of knowledge in all aspects of tree care. Together with references, this credential indicates the individual is qualified to consult on diagnosis, appraisal, and tree management.

Web Resources for Tree Information:
www.americanforests.org Champion Trees, conference in Charlotte, Nov 17-18, 2005
www.isa-arbor.com for the International Society of Arboriculture
www.treesaregood.com for ISA’s16 downloadable consumer information booklets
www.arborday.org for the National Arbor Day Foundation. Good workshops
www.wakegov.com/general/environment/keepamer Capital Trees Program, Wake County’s volunteer effort to promote the benefits of healthy trees
 
Thanx for the proper words, and great links Guy. i even see that keystone species function mentioned for the trees!

One of Doc Shigo's tree inspection for climbing warns that if you can't see the root flare it is a dangerous climb! i try to ***** root connection as well as joint connection for supports of loading. Wouldn't want to fail an included bark codominanat on my head etc.! (even if some would accuse me of having already done just that!)
 
i took over a large maple removal yesterday from another supervisor, I was going to stick with his original plan till he wasnt in charge anymore. The tree had been dead for a couple of years, after removing it I saw evidence of armallaria, with secondary pathogen breakdown. The tree had large woundwood grown upa 20' catface I still thought it might be strong enough to swing short trunk peices from the neighboring removal, estimated sound wood at 40% while making room for the GCRS I saw how rotten the reaction wood was that was when I reversed my plan. Anyway the other climber has been removing trees for 21 years he is quite decent, I didnt think his original plan was the best for different reasons, yet when I told him about the tree he acted noncha;lant about it.
 
FWIW the white oak in the pic had Armilaria. The consultant sent in samples from the dig to a lab that came back negative. No sign of decay on the stump after removal. Wasn't until stump grinding that extensive decay was found below grade.
 
Originally posted by TheTreeSpyder
i even see that keystone species function mentioned for the trees!
Yeah I borrowed that (not species or genera but life form) from you KC; hope you don't mind!
 
But rather i feel complimented; as i still digest all of the implications in simple '1 liners' of yours like "Tree chips belong to the site" etc.

i was wondering if you had such a clean definition for describing the visual differance between callus and woundwood?

Are there joints that are neither collared nor co-dominate?

Found this glossary that some might like: LA Parks and Recreations Tree Definitions

Thanx,
KC
 
Last edited:

Latest posts

Back
Top