One hand saw that does it all?

Arborist Forum

Help Support Arborist Forum:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.
Most come with a scabbard or sheath. If not you need to get one. I would not want to climb with an unsheathed handsaw. A good way to loose a finger or two... There are many options out there for saws and scabbards/sheaths.
 
Most come with a scabbard or sheath. If not you need to get one. I would not want to climb with an unsheathed handsaw. A good way to loose a finger or two... There are many options out there for saws and scabbards/sheaths.

Yeah, and every newb needs to watch where the left hand is as the right hand cuts. Follow through can be a bloody mess. Have a lot of bandages in the truck for the first few years.

It's been a while since I have whacked myself, but i can still remember those nasty puncture wounds
 
A freind of mine liked Fanno ( money thing), he would use a piece of rawhide string through the hole in the handle and tie a loop to fit his wrist so he could let go of it and his bracelet would hold it. Man, he had ugly elbows and then hung it off his saddle to climb and all his pants had massive cuts. I asked him why not use a scabbard, and he said he did not think it was worth the price.
Jeff :)
 
A lot of the old school guys would carry them without a scabbard. Just makes good sense to me. Especially with all of the band-aids I have went through even with using a scabbard...
 
Again?

This "which is the best handsaw" thread keeps coming up, and the results are invariably the same: everybody seems to prefer the Silky saws. I haven't ever used one, so I am not in a good position to offer a comparison, but I do have a question: How do you sharpen them?

I know they can be sharpened with a special file, but does anyone do it? Or do you just give up and buy a new blade when it gets dull?

My old favorite doesn't snag a rope, and it can be sharpened with the same 5/32nd round file that I use on the 200T. It is about 5-8 years old, and still cuts as good as the day I bought it.

previous thread:
http://www.arboristsite.com/showpost.php?p=1470341&postcount=3
(click the upper right corner to read the whole thread)

pics of my saw: http://www.arboristsite.com/showpost.php?p=1470523&postcount=6
 
Last edited:
...
Here's another beginner question for ya.< Do you have a lanyard attached to your hand saw? >
Thanks again.

No.

If I drop it, it won't get hurt or cost me a fortune. If you are worried about hanging onto your hand saw, you perhaps should not consider climbing trees, where a good grip is rather important.

Chainsaw lanyard? Almost always.
 
No.

If I drop it, it won't get hurt or cost me a fortune. If you are worried about hanging onto your hand saw, you perhaps should not consider climbing trees, where a good grip is rather important.

Chainsaw lanyard? Almost always.

Why is it every time someone asks a question on here, someone who thinks they are so great seems to make the comment that "they should not climb"? Are they really THAT conceded?
I simply asked a question and now someone challenges my ability to climb. I can asure you I can climb and cut just fine.
 
sounds as if no one here uses the Samurai Ichiban by Kanzawa. Cuts as well if not better than the Zubat, lasts longer if anything. And about $20 cheaper.

Or, you can go with the basic HD saw, same handle, but with a thicker, non fancy hollow ground blade, for just $23. Cuts well, and lasts....

Wesspur and Bishop carry them.
 
Wold tools poles saw er to about 3 .5 m the saw head detaches and converts to a hand saw with a push button click. Had one in the ute for 10 years they work well when new and sharp I go though saw head 6 months and pole yearly most have ended up bent or worn as it gets used daily pullin hangas and trimming low limbs.

http://www.newagearbor.com.au/shop/prod245.htm
 
This "which is the best handsaw" thread keeps coming up, and the results are invariably the same: everybody seems to prefer the Silky saws. I haven't ever used one, so I am not in a good position to offer a comparison, but I do have a question: How do you sharpen them?

I know they can be sharpened with a special file, but does anyone do it? Or do you just give up and buy a new blade when it gets dull?



]

I suppose you could sharpen it...but it would be a fiddly time consuming job I think, what with all the cutting surfaces...
I buy a new blade, or if I'm strapped for cash (as now) I rotate through old blades and find one that is not too bad...maybe one I changed for a new one when I was flush and felt like buying some 'new stuff'...before it really needed to be changed!
 
I suppose you could sharpen it...but it would be a fiddly time consuming job I think, what with all the cutting surfaces...
I buy a new blade, or if I'm strapped for cash (as now) I rotate through old blades and find one that is not too bad...maybe one I changed for a new one when I was flush and felt like buying some 'new stuff'...before it really needed to be changed!

No offense pdq.. but I couldn't imagine the state of cheapness that would drive someone to such madness as trying to sharpen a handsaw.. just sayin.
 
Why is it every time someone asks a question on here, someone who thinks they are so great seems to make the comment that "they should not climb"? Are they really THAT conceded?
I simply asked a question and now someone challenges my ability to climb. I can asure you I can climb and cut just fine.

I was not trying to be critical, nor to suggest that you couldn't climb. Please keep in mind that it was YOU that asked the question. I gave you a response that attempted to address the emotional reason for your question. You were concerned that you might drop the saw, I answered that it probably wouldn't be hurt if you did, and that if dropping things was a big concern, you might consider doing some introspection about your career path.

Since you seem to have drawn offense, I will elaborate on a logical basis.

If you have a lanyard on your hand saw, it will likely get snagged on something. Since we frequently use the handsaw for extended reach situations where we cannot run the chainsaw one-handed, this would require that we have a rather long lanyard, so as to remain attached. When you return the lanyard to its scabbard, now you will have all that extra lanyard hanging around your waist and feet, potentially tying you up when you least expect it.

Furthermore, I presume that you would have a chainsaw lanyard as well. This sets you up for lost time in the tree when the two lanyards begin to get crossed with each other. Add to that little inconvenience the fact that a lanyard would probably need to be attached with light carabiners, which would add to the complexity of attachments on your climbing saddle.

I routinely climb a tree with 10 nylon loopies and carabiners mounted on a rescue-8, a chainsaw with lanyard, a foot ascender, a hand ascender with a foot strap and bungee, an accessory cord with carabiners to hang things from my hand ascender (including myself), my buck strap with Bee line prussic and micro pulley, my climbing rope with Bee line prussic and micro pulley, and ... my handsaw with scabbard.

I cannot imagine the need for adding more complexity to all that equipment.

BTW: I suspect that you had intended to say "conceited". Conceded means that you have given up the conflict, which just isn't the sort of thing that folks do too often here at AS. "Conceited", as you have noticed, is a big problem.
Am I conceited? ... I prefer to think of it as "highly qualified" !
 
Last edited:
No offense pdq.. but I couldn't imagine the state of cheapness that would drive someone to such madness as trying to sharpen a handsaw.. just sayin.

That is my point EXACTLY about my favorite hand saw. It is easier to sharpen than a chainsaw, and we all do that regularly without complaint. There are only 46 (rather aggressive) teeth on my 18" saw, so it is not really much different than hand filing my 200T.

Nobody seems to sharpen their handsaw on a regular basis, so they get duller & duller, and...we quit taking them up the tree when we don't feel like getting a new one. Or you hit a nail and dull it on the job. Or you get careless with it, and it rusts up after a wet day, or...

I consider that the single advantage of always being able to keep it incredibly sharp outweighs all other advantages offered by other brands and styles of hand saws. Naturally, most of you guys look at it differently.
 
Last edited:

Latest posts

Back
Top