Neither is the poplar growing in Nebraska. I burn it all the time, especially for starting the fire in the stove, and it never pops or crackles. It lights like a charm and dries in six months. Folks also love it for campfire wood.Tulip poplar and poplar are different things. Do they have tulip poplar in NY, or are you talking about cottonwood/Aspen trees? I've never burned tulip poplar, but I would say from my experience burning the poplar we have in WI, that it's not particularly poppy.