True value of a tach?
I know that having a tach versus tuning by ear is all the rage these days, but I think this is misguided, over simplified, thinking. Before I go any further, I have to admit that I have one myself, the small one made for Stihl, DET 303. It is a nice small unit and has an ungodly projected battery life of somewhere around 20,000 hrs. Turns itself on when needed and then turns itself off when not needed so battery life is not likely to be an issue. Here`s the rub, I don`t think these tachs are accurate enough. I vaguely seem to remember reading that they have an accuracy somewhere around ± 10%. Someone correct me if I am recalling this wrong, but if I`m right, think about what that means on a saw running between 13k and 14k rpm. When I was deciding which one to buy, this or the larger Stihl tach with replaceable batteries, the specs were the same as I recall, and there was only about a $15 difference(dealer price) so I opted for the smaller one. After using this tach periodically for a few years now I have found that I routinely set the saw to run leaner using manufacturers specs and the tach, than I do when using my "calibrated ear". I noticed this early on, and the evidence has been born out by observation of ease of starting, off idle performance, color of the sparkplug, and most importantly, timed cuts in hardwood logs to justify my own suspicions. Remember here Guys, that the manufacturers have to satisfy the EPA as well as the consumers, and I think they generally choose a number that is just a hair on the lean side. EPA regs are getting progressively tighter on chainsaws and with two stroke engines that routinely blow up to 30% of the unburned fuel mixture out the exhaust, by the nature of their design, running a little lean can mean some substantial decreases in engine emissions when being tested for the EPA. Manufacturers serve many masters, and if they don`t satisfy the government agencies with jurisdiction, it`s a moot point what the level of customer satisfaction is. I don`t believe that using a tach will make a skilled saw user any better at engine tuning, than adding a scope to a rifle will make you an expert marksman. You still need to be adept at the fundamentals. Just my random thoughts. Russ