These sorts of Which rope ... ? threads can produce a lot of seemingly
contradictory responses, unless a little more information is provided which
can make replies more helpful.
--what ropes have you used (your domain for comparison),
--what climbing system(s) ... used
--how much do you weigh (lard butts vs. liteweights)
--how long (climbing hours (months/years)) do you use your rope
... and, what other considerations?
With fuller information in reply, when Sue claims to favor A over B, etc..,
Hans's prior favoring of B won't seem contradictory if he's not tried A,
but in comparing to C & D & E. Or if Sue, a liteweight, likes the feel of
X and finds Y too klunky, but Hans, a lardbutt, thinks Y is just right!
What does Goldilocks use? Big Bear doesn't care!
Citing tensile strength in a climbing line begs the question: How does that
matter, at all? --one could say that they're all equally strong, never breaking
during climbing, right? Or is the intent to retire a line to some load-bearing
duty?
*kN*
ps: Don't forget the all-important fashion question: What COLOR(s) ... ?!