Dude! You have got to be kidding....You must tell us more! Got any pics?
No. I deliberately didn't take any pictures. I am ashamed that I even let those fools go there without me. It was incomprehensible how they did it. I guess I can admit to what they did:
They went to the cemetary ill-prepared for a large tree, and didn't have any of the "big" saws. We have an agreement to remove a number of trees "in our spare time", so we went there that day to keep the crew busy. The manager at the cemetary pointed at the largest tree there, and they stupidly went to work on a job that they were unqualified for. I was not consulted, despite the fact that the crew had communication.
My climber took off the bottom 1/2 of the tree, then chickened out, and decided to flop the tree.
There were no phone calls to me until my truck was on it's side. They were using our 6 ton knuckleboom crane to pull over a 4' dbh dead oak tree. It was big, in every respect. Too bad they didn't have any big saws with them, because he was gnawing on this monster with a 24" bar.
After they decided the crane couldn't pull the tree over, they got some help. The idiots at the cemetary (their supervisor said he would never have approved) put their backhoe pushing against the back cut side.
That wasn't enough, either. You would have thought that SOMEBODY would have figured out it was easier to cut the tree down than to break it off!. So they attached our one ton truck to the MIDDLE of the rope the crane was attached to and then continued to gnaw on the tree with the undersized saw. I guess the guy in the one ton figured he would step on the gas and pull the tree over. There was apparently no coordination of efforts.
Everything moved but the tree.
As you can imagine, the crane was pulled over by the idiot in the F-350. This left a 65' tall dead tree that could not be safely climbed: at least 1/2 of the trunk had been cut, and there was no way to assess how strong the remaining trunk was. In fact, when we roped down one of the upper branches, the whole trunk shook in a scary fashion. I figured that too much of that, and we might break off the last of the holding wood, and crush the bucket truck with the operator in it.
When I finished the tree yesterday, I tried to evaluate how much wood had NOT been cut on the original attempts to pull the tree over. There was a strip of wood only 4" from the bark that had not been cut. Most of the back cut was only 12" to 18" deep, which means that there was NO WAY that tree was coming over yet.
We brought the tree down to about 33' tall trunk section, and I polished it off about 5'-6' above the ground, about 18" above the previous cuts. Even with a notch to about 1/2 tree diameter, wedges pounded in hard on the back side, we still had to pull that behemoth over with the truck. I tested the tension on the line [TIGHT!], and went back to the tree to take out more of the hinge wood. When the tree finally flopped, there was only about 1/2" of hinge wood left.
My sincere thanks to AS member Garfield, who brought his bucket truck on short notice to help me finish the job. I could have rented an aerial unit, but it would not have been as well suited for the job.