Spidey, you keep talking like oil and USED MOTOR oil are the same thing...some of us see a clear ( pun intended ) difference between the two.
It is fun jabbin at 'cha though...
Yeah, I know… fun.
I know the difference between the two, but these discussions, or arguments become so charged with emotion and misinformation it’s hard to remain… composed. Take for example the post by
Mac88, “
Anyone remember Times Beach?” Well, Times Beach doesn’t even belong in this thread… the dioxin contamination of Times Beach did not come from used motor oil proper, rather the waste oil sprayed on the roads for dust control had been itself contaminated. The waste hauler was mixing toxic waste from a chemical company with the used oil… that toxic waste contained dioxin levels believed to be as much as 2000 times higher than the levels found in Agent Orange. Times Beach was an industrial toxic waste issue, not a used (waste) oil issue. What the hell does that have to do with dumping a little used motor oil on a wood pile??
Now, I’m fully aware that burning used oil can
create dioxins, depending on the temperature of combustion
and the contents of the used oil (but still thousands of times less than the levels of Times Beach). Basically, if the combustion is belching black smoke, the chances are high for dioxin creation. But I’ve already said I don’t get black smoke from firewood that’s had used oil poured over it and allowed to sit for weeks or months… and if you’re burning in a stove with secondary combustion?? I can assure you the barrel where I burn my household trash pumps out more dioxins in one year than all the used oil I ever burned. Heck, a campfire creates dioxins…
OK, so there’s my Times Beach/dioxin argument. But the thing is, if I tried to mount an argument for every ill-conceived notion, or totally unrelated comment that gets brought into threads like this I’d be typing until next year. I get to the point where I just toss my arms up in the air, and my comments tend to look like they’ve gone-off-the-reservation… when in fact it’s the prior off-the-reservation comments that put me there.