I'm the other half of the Chain Throwers Anon support group. But it's only happened once so far.
I'm new to chainsaws, but been around a lot of other professional power tools for years, so I'm not unaccustomed to the Way of The Tool, just not chainsaws. I threw one chain last weekend - my first. Ever. It was a new chain, and I had tensioned it before use, but should have been watching the tension more closely as it was brand new (something I knew from reading here, but didn't apply well enough). It was on a small 1-2" tree that was in a mess of other stuff that I had thought was going to be a potential pinch hazard, but it still had to be cut. Well it got cut and pinched the chain and threw it. That was when I found the issue with driver dings and I didn't have a backup chain with me (another lesson). New to me, of course. Reasons it happened: 1. probably too little tension after a bit of use on a new chain. 2. small tree/pinch grab etc. I'll work on better tensioning now
But the question my friend the OP has is still a legitimate one. Does the chain catcher contribute to this damage? I am a big advocate of safety gear, but I also know that liability concerns can drive companies to do things at times that are safety related but are not really worth the trouble they cause. Being new to all this, I'm asking the same question. Sounds like several of you are saying without it, especially on the new saws with their much higher rpms, you risk at least severe saw damage and possibly injury. Makes sense. But just asking the question is not a bad thing, now is it?
Now it's almost Sat, so I get to try it again, learning from last week...
-Dave