Steve NW WI
Unwanted Riff Raff.
Read most of these posts at work, and thought about em, since they don't pay me to think, I spend a lot of time thinking of my own stuff
Like the BTU idea, I'll see what I can do. Please be patient. The fuel comparisons are already out there in many places, most wood stove companies have one on their site, just plug the numbers from this one into the wood cost portion.
While I like and agree with your thinking, I'm just trying to figure the cold hard cash cost of making the wood. You can add deductions as needed. Fact is it costs money to cut wood, I just want to get an idea how much.
That's something this sheet will be good at, once you have a solid set of numbers to work with. I'm just guessing on numbers right now, and will fill mine in with actual data as I go along. From helping the guys on the Interfaith cuts, I know I can block up a cord an hour pretty easily, but splitting and stacking are variables to put times with.
From some searching the 'net, including a couple of threads here, it seems most loggers and tree companies just expense their saws. They're not a huge cost compared to the "big" things like trucks, etc. I can and probably will come up with a way to depreciate them, just because to a homeowner, a saw or splitter is a relatively larger investment that should be considered over time.
Your calcs show your experiences, and most of the reason I came up with this was to not have to have the bad experiences to set my guidelines by
Like I said above, many of us here agree with your thinking. Heck, cutting trees that fall on my fields could be an expense if you look at it from the other side.
I personally think that it's a responsibility of owners of wooded land to make use of it, whether it's just hunting/recreation, firewood, commercial timber or whatnot.
More to come
Looks like a well thought out spread sheet.
If I may suggest another line of formulas for comparison? Cost per BTU value of the wood you are getting comparing that to the cost per BTU of your "other" source of heat be it NG, Oil, Propane etc etc. Assuming you have multiple forms of heating your home.
This would help in the "is it worth it" picture.
Like the BTU idea, I'll see what I can do. Please be patient. The fuel comparisons are already out there in many places, most wood stove companies have one on their site, just plug the numbers from this one into the wood cost portion.
Everyone else is saying to add this or that to the spreadsheet to make it more true to real life, but I say you need columns to subtract things as well.
While I like and agree with your thinking, I'm just trying to figure the cold hard cash cost of making the wood. You can add deductions as needed. Fact is it costs money to cut wood, I just want to get an idea how much.
It would be interesting to see what the actual savings is from going out cutting your own, or doing like me buying 10 cords logger load of oak delivered for $800 right to my cutting and stacking spot next to my garage. I know it cost me almost $9 to drive my pickup to work and back about 40 miles.
That's something this sheet will be good at, once you have a solid set of numbers to work with. I'm just guessing on numbers right now, and will fill mine in with actual data as I go along. From helping the guys on the Interfaith cuts, I know I can block up a cord an hour pretty easily, but splitting and stacking are variables to put times with.
(edited for length)
Regarding equipment, you really do want to capitalize your gear - even if you don't do it professionally. A $1000 saw (say a 372) should last a certain number of years. You need to pay attention to the amortized cost of your gear to avoid being stupid with the money. I would love to keep buying saws, but that would be just plain silly (but easy to rationalize in the heat of the moment).
I have simplified my calcs - if the wood is more than 35 minuntes away (one way) then I don't bother. If there is not enough to make at least 2 trips with the trailer (16,000lbs or more) then I am likely not going to bother. If the wood is all punky or pine then I am likely not going to try to get it.
From some searching the 'net, including a couple of threads here, it seems most loggers and tree companies just expense their saws. They're not a huge cost compared to the "big" things like trucks, etc. I can and probably will come up with a way to depreciate them, just because to a homeowner, a saw or splitter is a relatively larger investment that should be considered over time.
Your calcs show your experiences, and most of the reason I came up with this was to not have to have the bad experiences to set my guidelines by
Neat spreadsheet; I did one years ago when we landed Downeast on this woodlot. Money turned out to be the least important factor.
(edited for length)
I don't think about the cost of saws, PPE, skidding gear, ATV, or even the programs taken years ago. I'm having too much fun out there. For you sophisticates, it's a Gestault. Nice.
Like I said above, many of us here agree with your thinking. Heck, cutting trees that fall on my fields could be an expense if you look at it from the other side.
I personally think that it's a responsibility of owners of wooded land to make use of it, whether it's just hunting/recreation, firewood, commercial timber or whatnot.
More to come