Maple suddenly dropped large amount of bark, can I get some advice?

Arborist Forum

Help Support Arborist Forum:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.

Amin_1992

ArboristSite Operative
Joined
Mar 16, 2021
Messages
137
Reaction score
89
Location
East Coast USA
Hi guys, thanks for the advice. I'll start by saying I have a qualified arborist coming to inspect the tree next week. They've been good to me before, but i have to admit that they've almost always recommended taking down the tree, even ones that I thought were otherwise fine and years later are still doing fine...

Anyway, first day of above freezing temperatures today after a bad cold spell here, and I looked out front to see one of our maples dropped a ton of bark. About a third of the circumference, and probably 10 ft of length. Goes up about 12 feet or so, and the bark crack goes all the way to the flare.

My guess is that this is some sort of frost crack. The tree itself looks fine, and though the canopy isn't 100% full, it seemed to be a healthy tree that has never dropped any branches or looked abnormal to me in the last 6 years of living here.

Just planning ahead, what do you think about this tree? Normally I'd be open to taking it down, as I burn firewood anyhow, but this tree is in a tricky spot. It is right on the property line, on a slope facing my house, and with no real way or space to just drop it. No way to get a lift to it either... my thought is the only way to get it down will be for someone to climb and drop it in pieces, and even then there is a lot of risk of the logs landing and rolling toward the house and our landscaping.

Photos attached. Curious what you guys think. Thanks!
 

Attachments

  • 1000021648.jpg
    1000021648.jpg
    4.5 MB
  • 1000021649.jpg
    1000021649.jpg
    3.1 MB
  • 1000021647.jpg
    1000021647.jpg
    3.3 MB
  • 1000021646.jpg
    1000021646.jpg
    4 MB
  • 1000021645.jpg
    1000021645.jpg
    4.1 MB
Hi guys, thanks for the advice. I'll start by saying I have a qualified arborist coming to inspect the tree next week. They've been good to me before, but i have to admit that they've almost always recommended taking down the tree, even ones that I thought were otherwise fine and years later are still doing fine...

Anyway, first day of above freezing temperatures today after a bad cold spell here, and I looked out front to see one of our maples dropped a ton of bark. About a third of the circumference, and probably 10 ft of length. Goes up about 12 feet or so, and the bark crack goes all the way to the flare.

My guess is that this is some sort of frost crack. The tree itself looks fine, and though the canopy isn't 100% full, it seemed to be a healthy tree that has never dropped any branches or looked abnormal to me in the last 6 years of living here.

Just planning ahead, what do you think about this tree? Normally I'd be open to taking it down, as I burn firewood anyhow, but this tree is in a tricky spot. It is right on the property line, on a slope facing my house, and with no real way or space to just drop it. No way to get a lift to it either... my thought is the only way to get it down will be for someone to climb and drop it in pieces, and even then there is a lot of risk of the logs landing and rolling toward the house and our landscaping.

Photos attached. Curious what you guys think. Thanks!
I'm no expert, but that tree looks dead to me.
That looks like insect munching going on under the bark.
tree.jpg
Odd-looking root flares.
 
Hi guys, thanks for the advice. I'll start by saying I have a qualified arborist coming to inspect the tree next week. They've been good to me before, but i have to admit that they've almost always recommended taking down the tree, even ones that I thought were otherwise fine and years later are still doing fine...

Anyway, first day of above freezing temperatures today after a bad cold spell here, and I looked out front to see one of our maples dropped a ton of bark. About a third of the circumference, and probably 10 ft of length. Goes up about 12 feet or so, and the bark crack goes all the way to the flare.

My guess is that this is some sort of frost crack. The tree itself looks fine, and though the canopy isn't 100% full, it seemed to be a healthy tree that has never dropped any branches or looked abnormal to me in the last 6 years of living here.

Just planning ahead, what do you think about this tree? Normally I'd be open to taking it down, as I burn firewood anyhow, but this tree is in a tricky spot. It is right on the property line, on a slope facing my house, and with no real way or space to just drop it. No way to get a lift to it either... my thought is the only way to get it down will be for someone to climb and drop it in pieces, and even then there is a lot of risk of the logs landing and rolling toward the house and our landscaping.

Photos attached. Curious what you guys think. Thanks!
How about a portable Tracked Lift ?IMG_2387.jpeg
 
Hi guys, thanks for the advice. I'll start by saying I have a qualified arborist coming to inspect the tree next week. They've been good to me before, but i have to admit that they've almost always recommended taking down the tree, even ones that I thought were otherwise fine and years later are still doing fine...

Anyway, first day of above freezing temperatures today after a bad cold spell here, and I looked out front to see one of our maples dropped a ton of bark. About a third of the circumference, and probably 10 ft of length. Goes up about 12 feet or so, and the bark crack goes all the way to the flare.

My guess is that this is some sort of frost crack. The tree itself looks fine, and though the canopy isn't 100% full, it seemed to be a healthy tree that has never dropped any branches or looked abnormal to me in the last 6 years of living here.

Just planning ahead, what do you think about this tree? Normally I'd be open to taking it down, as I burn firewood anyhow, but this tree is in a tricky spot. It is right on the property line, on a slope facing my house, and with no real way or space to just drop it. No way to get a lift to it either... my thought is the only way to get it down will be for someone to climb and drop it in pieces, and even then there is a lot of risk of the logs landing and rolling toward the house and our landscaping.

Photos attached. Curious what you guys think. Thanks!
Looks like dead/broken limbs up top too.
tree2.jpg
 
Back
Top