New piston in old liped cylinder?

[Mcfly49]

So which is it then?, is it worn or not in your 'expert' opinion

Ha, amazing what perfect lighting can do. I bet it took 30 pics before I could actually capture the dullness... what do you say now, I was going to say on film?

 

[bwalker]

So which is it then?, is it worn or not in your 'expert' opinion

After seeing the second pic it was obvious. The first pic was not and that's a weird wear pattern for a plated cylinder.