North Alabama fatality

Wesspur
Rugged made
Arborist Forum

Help Support Arborist Forum:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.
Elmore

Elmore

Addicted to ArboristSite
Joined
Feb 27, 2004
Messages
2,291
Reaction score
132
Location
North Alabama
Sunday, February 27, 2005
Huntsville Times
City firefighter killed when tree falls on him

An off-duty Huntsville city firefighter was killed when a tree fell on him Friday in Jackson County, a city fire official says.

Roy Manley Sr., 63, was cutting a tree when another tree fell and struck him in the back of the head, said Jay Gates, spokesman for Huntsville Fire & Rescue.

Manley, a driver-engineer at Station 4 on Monte Sano, had 38 years of service with the department, Gates said.
 
ray benson said:
Wow, I would like to read the details on it. Firemen are very safety orientated.
Click to expand...

Maybe when they do "fireman" stuff...

I saw a crew getting ready for a practice burn. A firefighter was on the boom of the ladder truck cutting away a limb. No attachment to the boom, one handing a rear handle saw, yup, REAR handle! He was leaning way out too. Four inch limb with no bottom cut. The branch ripped and pulled the saw down. Good thing he didn't get pulled off the boom. No STand Clear/All clear. Face shield down but no eye protection that would pass regs for treeworkers.

But...they weren't doing treework, they were doing "fireman" work so our rules don't apply.
 
Elmore said:
Sunday, February 27, 2005
Huntsville Times

Roy Manley Sr., 63, was cutting a tree when another tree fell and struck him in the back of the head
Click to expand...

Did he have a leaner in the tree he was cutting? Or did someone else drop a tree on him?
 
SOB Full Body Climbing Harness Can Be Inverted Thicken Widen Protect Waist Safety Harness Tree Work Rock Climbing Mountaineering Rescuing Work at Height
$103.98
SOB Full Body Climbing Harness Can Be Inverted Thicken Widen Protect Waist Safety Harness Tree Work Rock Climbing Mountaineering Rescuing Work at Height SOB-US
Hooyman Extendable Tree Saw 5 Foot with Lock Back Blade, Impulse Hardened Teeth, Locking Extension System, and Detachable Head Handsaw for Tree Trimming, Cutting, Pruning, Hunting, and Outdoors
-8%
$59.71 $64.99
Hooyman Extendable Tree Saw 5 Foot with Lock Back Blade, Impulse Hardened Teeth, Locking Extension System, and Detachable Head Handsaw for Tree Trimming, Cutting, Pruning, Hunting, and Outdoors Amazon.com
Weaver Leather WLC 315 Saddle with 1" Heavy Duty Coated Webbing Leg Straps, Medium, Brown/Red
-8%
$215.05 $233.19
Weaver Leather WLC 315 Saddle with 1" Heavy Duty Coated Webbing Leg Straps, Medium, Brown/Red equipatron
CRAYZA Double Braided Polyester Rope (1/2 in x 100 ft) Strong Arborist Rigging Rope 48 Strands for Tree Work Climbing Pulling Swing Sailing, Orange
$38.49 ($0.38 / foot)
CRAYZA Double Braided Polyester Rope (1/2 in x 100 ft) Strong Arborist Rigging Rope 48 Strands for Tree Work Climbing Pulling Swing Sailing, Orange CRAYZA
Firewood Log Splitter 45mm+32mm + 4 Handles (Square + Round + Hex Shank + Small Hex) Wood Log Splitter Easy Splitter Detachable Drill Bit Heavy Duty Electric Drills Screw Cone Driver Removable
$19.99 ($3.33 / Count)
Firewood Log Splitter 45mm+32mm + 4 Handles (Square + Round + Hex Shank + Small Hex) Wood Log Splitter Easy Splitter Detachable Drill Bit Heavy Duty Electric Drills Screw Cone Driver Removable JianShiMoQinDianZiShangWuYouXianGongSi
62Pcs Arborist Stickers Pack, Cartoon Cute Vinyl Waterproof Decals for Water Bottle,Laptop,Phone,Skateboard,Scrapbooking,Bumper for Kids Teens Adults Fans for Party Supply
$6.99
62Pcs Arborist Stickers Pack, Cartoon Cute Vinyl Waterproof Decals for Water Bottle,Laptop,Phone,Skateboard,Scrapbooking,Bumper for Kids Teens Adults Fans for Party Supply Feihe Co., Ltd
Oregon Q90407 Chainsaw Sharpening and Guide Bar Maintenance Kit
$69.02
Oregon Q90407 Chainsaw Sharpening and Guide Bar Maintenance Kit Express-Shipping-24hr ✅
VEVOR Manual Pole Saw, 7.3-27 ft Extendable Tree Pruner, Sharp Steel Blade High Branches Trimming, Manual Branch Trimmer with Lightweight 8 Fiberglass Handles, for Pruning Palms and Shrubs
$76.55
VEVOR Manual Pole Saw, 7.3-27 ft Extendable Tree Pruner, Sharp Steel Blade High Branches Trimming, Manual Branch Trimmer with Lightweight 8 Fiberglass Handles, for Pruning Palms and Shrubs Amazon.com
BAYTORY Extendable Tree Pruner Saw Head Without Pole, High-Altitude Branches Trimmer Pruning Shears, Harvester Clipper for Plant Twig Vine, Garden Trimming Tool
$27.97
BAYTORY Extendable Tree Pruner Saw Head Without Pole, High-Altitude Branches Trimmer Pruning Shears, Harvester Clipper for Plant Twig Vine, Garden Trimming Tool BAYTORY
SaidiCo 46" Bungee Chain Saw Strap W/ 2" Ring & 225-4-1/4" Long Snap
$24.95
SaidiCo 46" Bungee Chain Saw Strap W/ 2" Ring & 225-4-1/4" Long Snap GoldenwestLawnmowers
HeeJo Climbing, Safety Safe Seat Belt for Outdoor Tree Climbing, Outward Band Expanding Training Large Size,Climbing Gear
$65.99
HeeJo Climbing, Safety Safe Seat Belt for Outdoor Tree Climbing, Outward Band Expanding Training Large Size,Climbing Gear HeeJo
ZELARMAN Chainsaw Chaps 8-layer Protective Apron Wrap Adjustable Chainsaw Pants/Chap for Loggers Forest Workers Class A
-11%
$79.99 $89.99
ZELARMAN Chainsaw Chaps 8-layer Protective Apron Wrap Adjustable Chainsaw Pants/Chap for Loggers Forest Workers Class A QUALITY GARDEN & HAND TOOLS
EGO Power+ EP7500 31-Inch Extension Pole Attachment for Power Head PH1400 and Saw PSA1000
$69.00
EGO Power+ EP7500 31-Inch Extension Pole Attachment for Power Head PH1400 and Saw PSA1000 Amazon.com
Primachen Wall Mounted Kindling Splitter, 2024 New Designed Kindling Splitter for Wood Outdoor Indoor, Manual Log Splitter Hand Firewood Splitter with Extended Handle
$68.99
Primachen Wall Mounted Kindling Splitter, 2024 New Designed Kindling Splitter for Wood Outdoor Indoor, Manual Log Splitter Hand Firewood Splitter with Extended Handle Primachen
HeeJo Climbing, Treestand, Tree Working, Safety Safe Seat Belt for Outdoor Tree Climbing, Large Size
$46.99
HeeJo Climbing, Treestand, Tree Working, Safety Safe Seat Belt for Outdoor Tree Climbing, Large Size HeeJo
Fiskars Pole Saw Blade Replacement for Fiskars Pruning Saws and Tree Pruners, 15 Inch Saw Blade with Woodzig Chainsaw-Style Saw Tooth Design
-11%
$15.95 ($15.95 / Count) $17.99 ($17.99 / Count)
Fiskars Pole Saw Blade Replacement for Fiskars Pruning Saws and Tree Pruners, 15 Inch Saw Blade with Woodzig Chainsaw-Style Saw Tooth Design OKB85
Notch Big Shot Kit with Trigger (Set1029D)
$214.95
Notch Big Shot Kit with Trigger (Set1029D) R&L Supply LLC
Weaver Leather 08-98226 (-BO) Arborist Bungee Chain Saw Strap, Orange - 33 1/2", 33-1/2" with Two Rings
$17.79
Weaver Leather 08-98226 (-BO) Arborist Bungee Chain Saw Strap, Orange - 33 1/2", 33-1/2" with Two Rings Amazon.com
HOSKO 10FT Pole Saw for Tree Trimming, Long Extension Pruning Saw, Blade Tree Trimmer Pole, Manual Pole Cutter for, Yard Garden and Patios Trees Branches Cutting
$32.99
HOSKO 10FT Pole Saw for Tree Trimming, Long Extension Pruning Saw, Blade Tree Trimmer Pole, Manual Pole Cutter for, Yard Garden and Patios Trees Branches Cutting HOSKO
Pruning Manual Hand Saw // Hand Held or with Extension Manual Pole Saw for Tree Trimming // Fits All Extension Poles with Standard US Acme Thread // Tree Limb Hand Saw (Pole Sold Separately)
$25.97
Pruning Manual Hand Saw // Hand Held or with Extension Manual Pole Saw for Tree Trimming // Fits All Extension Poles with Standard US Acme Thread // Tree Limb Hand Saw (Pole Sold Separately) Extend-A-Reach
Oregon Chainsaw Protective Trousers Yukon Class 1 Small (295435/S)
$177.02
Oregon Chainsaw Protective Trousers Yukon Class 1 Small (295435/S) Express-Shipping-24hr ✅
Notch Apron Style Chainsaw Chaps - Large (CCHAPR-L)
$52.99
Notch Apron Style Chainsaw Chaps - Large (CCHAPR-L) SHERRILLtree
Ttechouter Adjustable Thickness Climbing Harness Half Body Harnesses for Fire Rescuing Caving Rock Climbing Rappelling Tree Protect Waist Safety Belts
-26%
$36.99 $49.99
Ttechouter Adjustable Thickness Climbing Harness Half Body Harnesses for Fire Rescuing Caving Rock Climbing Rappelling Tree Protect Waist Safety Belts Techouter
Weavor Arborist Speedline Kit
$308.99
Weavor Arborist Speedline Kit Amazon.com
Extendable Tree Pruner Saw Head Without Pole, Outdoor High-Altitude Branches Trimmer Pruning Shears, Harvester Clipper for Plant Twig Vine, Garden Trimming Tool
$19.82
Extendable Tree Pruner Saw Head Without Pole, Outdoor High-Altitude Branches Trimmer Pruning Shears, Harvester Clipper for Plant Twig Vine, Garden Trimming Tool Jiejiexinshop
GREENER XL Firewood Log Splitter with Open Top - Solid Cast Steel Kindling Wood Splitter with Wedge, Heavy Duty Manual Log Splitter for Firewood, Wood Splitting Cutter Kindling Cracker Tool, Portable
$89.99
GREENER XL Firewood Log Splitter with Open Top - Solid Cast Steel Kindling Wood Splitter with Wedge, Heavy Duty Manual Log Splitter for Firewood, Wood Splitting Cutter Kindling Cracker Tool, Portable GREENER STORE
NoCry 6-in-1 Industrial Chainsaw Helmet with Face Shield and Ear Muffs - Includes a Mesh Chainsaw Face Shield & a Clear Plastic Face Visor - ANSI Z89.1 Certified Forestry Helmet or Arborist Helmet
-13%
$39.99 $45.99
NoCry 6-in-1 Industrial Chainsaw Helmet with Face Shield and Ear Muffs - Includes a Mesh Chainsaw Face Shield & a Clear Plastic Face Visor - ANSI Z89.1 Certified Forestry Helmet or Arborist Helmet NoCry Work Gear
Arborist Rigging Rope 1/2 in x 150 Ft Blue Bull Rope Polyester Braided Arborist Rope 1/2 inch 48 Strands 150 Feet for Various Outdoor Applications Construction Climbing Swing Sailing
-14%
$59.99 ($0.40 / Foot) $69.79 ($0.47 / Foot)
Arborist Rigging Rope 1/2 in x 150 Ft Blue Bull Rope Polyester Braided Arborist Rope 1/2 inch 48 Strands 150 Feet for Various Outdoor Applications Construction Climbing Swing Sailing Glfcai store
BILT HARD Electric Log Splitter 6.5 Ton with Stand, Wood Splitter Electric Powered 15 Amp Motor with Hydraulic Ram, Firewood Splitting Machine, Horizontal
$349.99
BILT HARD Electric Log Splitter 6.5 Ton with Stand, Wood Splitter Electric Powered 15 Amp Motor with Hydraulic Ram, Firewood Splitting Machine, Horizontal Hykolity
HandAcc Climbing belts, Thicken Professional Safety Belt for Caving Rock Climbing Fire Rescuing Rappelling Tree and Outdoor Adventure Activities
-32%
$33.99 $49.99
HandAcc Climbing belts, Thicken Professional Safety Belt for Caving Rock Climbing Fire Rescuing Rappelling Tree and Outdoor Adventure Activities HandAcc.Store
Arborists' Certification Study Guide, 4th Edition
$147.45
Arborists' Certification Study Guide, 4th Edition Apex_media🍏
NewDoar Right Hand Ascender Rock Climbing Tree Arborist Rappelling Gear Equipment CE Certified Rope Clamp for 8~13MM Rope(Right Hand)
$36.99
NewDoar Right Hand Ascender Rock Climbing Tree Arborist Rappelling Gear Equipment CE Certified Rope Clamp for 8~13MM Rope(Right Hand) Meituo
Weaver Arborist Bungee Chain Saw Strap
$17.39
Weaver Arborist Bungee Chain Saw Strap Amazon.com
Champion Power Equipment 7-Ton Compact Horizontal Gas Log Splitter with Auto Return
$599.99
Champion Power Equipment 7-Ton Compact Horizontal Gas Log Splitter with Auto Return Amazon.com
Fiskars 8 lb. Splitting Maul - 36" Shock-Absorbing, Comfort Grip Handle - Rust Resistant Forged Steel Blade - Wood Splitter Maul for Hardwood - Split Wood for Campfires - Bushcraft Gear
-25%
$59.49 $78.99
Fiskars 8 lb. Splitting Maul - 36" Shock-Absorbing, Comfort Grip Handle - Rust Resistant Forged Steel Blade - Wood Splitter Maul for Hardwood - Split Wood for Campfires - Bushcraft Gear Amazon.com
SOB Climbing Harness, Half Body Tree Climbing Harness Men,Thicken Widen Protect Waist Safety Harness for Arborist Harness,Working Rescuing at Height Safety Belt Harness
$64.99
SOB Climbing Harness, Half Body Tree Climbing Harness Men,Thicken Widen Protect Waist Safety Harness for Arborist Harness,Working Rescuing at Height Safety Belt Harness SOB-US
HandAcc Climbing belts, Thicken Professional Half Body Safety Belt Climbing Gear for Tree Climbing, Fire Rescue, Rappelling and Other Outdoor Adventure Activities
$35.99
HandAcc Climbing belts, Thicken Professional Half Body Safety Belt Climbing Gear for Tree Climbing, Fire Rescue, Rappelling and Other Outdoor Adventure Activities HandAcc.Store
FORESTER Chainsaw Protective Pants – Lightweight 360 Degree Class A Safety Protection for Forestry and Arborist (29-30) Black
$199.95
FORESTER Chainsaw Protective Pants – Lightweight 360 Degree Class A Safety Protection for Forestry and Arborist (29-30) Black MGP Supply
YARDMARIS Chainsaw Pants, Technical Chainsaw Trouser, Chainsaw Chaps, Tree Cutting Pant with Adjustable Suspenders
$229.99
YARDMARIS Chainsaw Pants, Technical Chainsaw Trouser, Chainsaw Chaps, Tree Cutting Pant with Adjustable Suspenders YARDMARIS
Forester Protective Clothing - OEM Forestry Cutter Combo Kit Apron Chaps Helmet Face Shield Ear Muffs Safety Glasses Arborist Equipment Chainsaw Pants Logging Tools Helmet Accessories Orange
$99.99
Forester Protective Clothing - OEM Forestry Cutter Combo Kit Apron Chaps Helmet Face Shield Ear Muffs Safety Glasses Arborist Equipment Chainsaw Pants Logging Tools Helmet Accessories Orange MGP Supply
ESTWING Sure Split Wedge - 5-Pound Wood Splitting Tool with Forged Steel Construction & 1-7/8" Cutting Edge - E-5
$23.98
ESTWING Sure Split Wedge - 5-Pound Wood Splitting Tool with Forged Steel Construction & 1-7/8" Cutting Edge - E-5 Amazon.com
YARDMARIS Chainsaw Chaps Technical 8 Layers Chainsaw Pants Class B for Chainsaw Users
$79.99
YARDMARIS Chainsaw Chaps Technical 8 Layers Chainsaw Pants Class B for Chainsaw Users YARDMARIS
PETZL Zigzag Descender for Arborists D022AA00
-14%
$211.13 $245.50
PETZL Zigzag Descender for Arborists D022AA00 WesternRoute
Husqvarna Functional Saw Protection Gloves, Large
$33.85
Husqvarna Functional Saw Protection Gloves, Large MPartsman
ZELARMAN Chainsaw Chaps Apron Wrap 8-layer for Men/Women Loggers Forest Workers Protective Chain Saw Pants Adjustable
$63.99
ZELARMAN Chainsaw Chaps Apron Wrap 8-layer for Men/Women Loggers Forest Workers Protective Chain Saw Pants Adjustable QUALITY GARDEN & HAND TOOLS
Arborist Knots – Knot Cards for Tree Climbing – 14 Page Waterproof Pocket Knot Guide for Arborist Equipment Kit with 14 Tree Care Knots - Includes Wire Loop
$8.99
Arborist Knots – Knot Cards for Tree Climbing – 14 Page Waterproof Pocket Knot Guide for Arborist Equipment Kit with 14 Tree Care Knots - Includes Wire Loop ReferenceReady
ZIAERKOR Tree Climbing Gear Non-Slip with Adjustable Climbing Belt, Tree Climbing Spikes for Tree Work Thickened Steel Professional Tools Arborist Climbing for Picking Fruit, Logging
$189.99
ZIAERKOR Tree Climbing Gear Non-Slip with Adjustable Climbing Belt, Tree Climbing Spikes for Tree Work Thickened Steel Professional Tools Arborist Climbing for Picking Fruit, Logging statelytrees
SuperHandy Log Splitter Electric Portable 6 Ton Ram System 1-3/4eHP 15Amp 1500Watt Motor Horizontal Full Beam with Steel Wedge for Fire Wood Splitting Forestry Harvesting
-9%
$364.99 $400.00
SuperHandy Log Splitter Electric Portable 6 Ton Ram System 1-3/4eHP 15Amp 1500Watt Motor Horizontal Full Beam with Steel Wedge for Fire Wood Splitting Forestry Harvesting Woot
Wood Kindling Splitter - The Firewood Kindling Tool for Wood Stove Fireplace and Fire Pit
-8%
$36.99 $39.99
Wood Kindling Splitter - The Firewood Kindling Tool for Wood Stove Fireplace and Fire Pit UniExtra
HandAcc Climbing belts, Thicken Professional Large Size Safety Seat Belts for Tree Climbing, Rescuing Work, Rappelling and Other Outdoor Adventure Activities
-33%
$53.99 $79.99
HandAcc Climbing belts, Thicken Professional Large Size Safety Seat Belts for Tree Climbing, Rescuing Work, Rappelling and Other Outdoor Adventure Activities HandAcc.Store
BILT HARD Log Splitter 6.5 Ton, Wood Splitter Electric Powered 15Amp, with Hydraulic Ram, Electric Firewood Splitting Machine, Horizontal
$309.99
BILT HARD Log Splitter 6.5 Ton, Wood Splitter Electric Powered 15Amp, with Hydraulic Ram, Electric Firewood Splitting Machine, Horizontal Hykolity
Sorry for the guy, thats too bad. About firemen, 99% boredom, 1% bravery&danger. Mostly good guys but I think that some of them really think they know it all. I saw them hosing down a three-phase transformer that was on fire. We were doing res. a few houses away, all of us utility arborists. One guy from our crew called the emergency phone # of the utility, asked them to de-energize the line, walked over to the firemen and told them to get back and stop spraying. The head guy looked at him like he was retarded and said "we are firemen!". Cant judge what happened here without a fatality investigation report. Sometimes even the very best fallers get thier ticket punched by crazy stuff beyond thier control. Sad.
 
dayman said:
I saw a crew getting ready for a practice burn. A firefighter was on the boom of the ladder truck cutting away a limb. No attachment to the boom, one handing a rear handle saw, yup, REAR handle! He was leaning way out too. Four inch limb with no bottom cut. The branch ripped and pulled the saw down. Good thing he didn't get pulled off the boom. No STand Clear
Click to expand...

I've heard of fatalities in our industry during the practice of rescue climbs. Such a bummer to try to prepare for the worst, only to discover that the practice methods are dangerous in and of themselves. But it seems a lot of times, these disasters are the best learning tools.
My heart goes out to the Alabama man's family. Justdammit. <head down>
 

Similar threads

B
Man Dies Trimming Palm Tree
Replies
6
Views
2K
bmadams
B
GrizG
Dutchess County man, 38, killed while cutting down tree
Replies
2
Views
2K
Bmezz88
Bmezz88
P
City to pay $500K to man injured by flying log
3 4 5
Replies
88
Views
13K
rabbit box
R
C
And Another Homeowner Tree/Ladder Fatality
Replies
1
Views
3K
PhilKawasakiuser
P
slowp
Another Fatality
Replies
11
Views
2K
slowp
slowp

Latest posts

Back
Top