I second this. I have a pair of caulked Hoffmann's that are insulated are great in winter. Walking over logs, blow down or random crap is easy peasy. I don't fall down much anymore. They are pretty durable too. I get em' from a shop in Orofino, ID which is close to me. For regular summer use I have really liked Nick's boots in the past. Nowadays Nick's aren't as good as they use to be though. Frank's Boots out of Spokane seem to be where it's at right now! I'm having them rebuild an old pair of Nick's for me currently. Really good quality craftsmanship there! They don't tear up my feet and provide good arch and ankle support. They provide good protection from anything like construction, logging, firefighting, or welding. Obenauffs boot grease works great on them, I've been using the stuff for twenty years now.Hoffman Boots in Idaho.
Their leather top caulks, '2 in ones' are considered a winter boot but we use them through the summer even with the full thinsulate boots.
They are at the $200 range.
Go to logging sec on their site.
As far as the direct fire/coal exposure aspect I can illuminate a little bit of that. As far as wildland fire goes, you're going to end up in direct contact with fire, walking over hot coals/embers or briefly standing on them here and there. It's an inherent part of the job, more so if your on a crew, module or an engine that actually does stuff. Nick's, Frank's, Whites all provide great resistance to the heat but the direct contact does reduce the overall life of the boot. Wouldn't recommend Danners or Hawthornes for that though, not as good material in my opinion.
Sent from my SM-N970U using Tapatalk