my saw is a p 41 pionner and it has spark and good compression i can hold up the saw by the starter ropeIf your saw has good compression and spark at the right time and still won't run right or doesn't start you can look at the fuel system which a reed valve is part of. What kind of saw do you have?
if i do take off the carb should the reed valve be closed or open?If you determine it is a fuel problem, once you get the carburetor off it's not that much more trouble to take the reed plate off. On some saws like my Homelite Super 2 the reed plate came out while I was pulling the carb off.
The reed valve will be closed. It opens and closes when the engine runs. It probably wouldn't hurt if it shows a little gap between the flap and the block but best if it closes all the way. Mainly when you take the reed valves out you look for broken reeds, sometimes they'll even be missing..if i do take off the carb should the reed valve be closed or open?