It couldn't suck air from the broken tab...the plastic piece that the insulator wraps around? That part goes on the engine , before the carb, as you know. There is no gasket or sealing between the plastic piece, and the intake manifold. When the carb is worked into place, its inner face, presses against the ribs on the face of the intake. THATS the only seal. In more than 1 case, either the intake manifold is cracked, OR the ribbed rubber has degraded, is leaking, OR, the carb isn't tight.Interesting, I replaced part #504724701 which is called the insulation wall. It must have something to do with an air leak because it solved my problem. Furthermore, it was sucking air from where the clip was broken. In my experience any joint/seal past the carb needs to be correct or there will be a leak
I too fell under the insulator must be a sealing gasket thing.......now we know the rest of the story.