Stihl Chainsaw - which one would you suggest?

Arborist Forum

Help Support Arborist Forum:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.

rebldr

New Member
Joined
Apr 27, 2005
Messages
1
Reaction score
0
Location
Southern Wisconsin
I am a consumer who has lots of trees that need tending. I'm looking at the Stihl chainsaw and the two models I'm interested in are the MS361 and the MS 440 Magnum. For someone who uses a chainsaw every weekend and sometimes even more often, which of these saws would be better? We have lots of felled trees and they need to be cut up. Any suggestions about which of these saws would be best? Also, maybe there is another saw that you think is better - please share. Thank you for your help.
 
It's good to see that you've already got it narrowed down to a couple of models. But be advised that you'll get a bunch of other recommendations from guys on here later on down in this thread. Someone will mention the Dolmar 7900-someone always does. It's a good saw. Anyway, how big is the wood you're working with? Soft wood, hard wood? Standing timber, or already on the ground? I think you'll do just fine with the 361, as it can handle most of what you throw at it. I've got one, and can't say a bad thing about it. I've also got a 460, which is the 440's big brother and love it as well. In fact, I'm looking to fill that 5.5 hp gap with a 440 in the coming months. But if you're going to be in 20" oak or other hardwood, the 440 will make you a very happy customer. You might also look at a Husky 372, as they've been discontinued, and there's still some left that guys are snatching up pretty quickly. Very, very good saw, and I'm not even a Husky guy. You've got two very good saws picked out, and you'd be happy with either one. But like I said, if it's bigger, harder wood, the 440 would make easier work with it, and allow you more bar length options.

Let us know what you end up with.

Jeff
 
Mid sized Huskys would be good too! 372, 365 or even a 359. Any one of these saws or the ones that you mentioned will do the job for you and I'm sure you would be pleased. What size bar would you think about running? What size are the trees are you going to be cutting? If you are gonna be carrying the saw around a lot, then smaller is better (lighter) and then there is the cost of the larger saws. Many things to look at regarding which saw you might purchase. Dealer support is very helpful and can also be the determining factor to the purchase.
 
Husky

Do yourself a favor and get a Husqvarna 372XP while you can. You will not be disappointed. One of the best saws ever made.
 
MS 440. I've owned Stihls for over 20 years and my MS 440 for over a year. It's the best saw I have ever owned. I've never had problems with any of them, but the 440 is a superb combination of power, weight, and features.

Joe
 
If you go 70cc class, your decision can be difficult. That is a very competitive class. The MS 440, 372XP, and Dolmar PS-7300 are all winners. The one advantage that the Dolmar and Husqvarna have is price. You can expect to get set up with either of those for under $600. If dealer support is an issue, than that could steer you towards the Stihl. The Dolmar has a little more power and a little more weight than the other two, but the best power to weight ratio. As mentioned, the PS-7900 gives you a little more power on the same chasis, but along with that comes a bigger price tag. Compared to the Stihl MS460 though, it is the clear winner.

That being said, I think you would be happier in the 60cc class, in which the MS361 would be an excellent, if not the best, choice. The next best thing would be the Husqvarna 357XP and 359 in that order. Dolmar does not have a standout around 60cc's. The PS-6400 is the best they have, and is a good saw, but designed on the same chasis (same weight) as the larger PS-7300 and PS-7900. The nearest comparisons for power and weight would be the Husqvarna 365, Echo CS-670, or Stihl
MS390.
 
Worked today slashing trees on a r.o.w.. Three saws, two ms 361s and an old 272xp, being the foreman I took the 272xp of course. Stihl have made some very good saws, no doubt, but the 361 is not one of them. Some here say they are great, but they are not really a pro saw. Stupid caps, soft motor mounts, not quickly revving like a Husky, get a 372xp, can't recommend a 357 or a 365 for bucking, the 357 doesn't have the power and the 365 isn't an xp so it it is not as good as a 372xp. Maybe the 440 is o.k. never used one.
 
I work in a shop where you take out what you need for the day. We have enough gear and saws to handle most everything.

The Husky 372's are picked out quick, the Stihl 044's are gone next, the Stihl 361 is everyone's last dance partner, still looks new. The 034's get more of a look.

The 361 doesn't have any midrange power, it bogs out too easy. Goes from pulling high revs to nothin'.

If there's a Husky 372 available, grab it.

Your feel about your local dealer(s) should tell the tale between Husky or Stihl.

RedlineIt.
 
372xp is my saw of choice. I wouldn't trade mine for two brand new 440's. I also have a very nice 359 of course it is ported a bit, as is the 372. my dad has a stock 361 and I have run it. with a 16" bar on it it is a pretty decent saw. it is very soft feeling in the cut due to the new antivibe. has good top end, but doesn't seem to have a lot of grunt in the middle and low end. I would not buy a 440 if I were you, the 372 is a much better saw at a better price. the 361 is a nice saw, but the price is way too high. also don't care for the intellecarb thingamajig. the 359 is the best value in the 60cc class. if you get the 359, you can spend the extra cash you save on a porting job, and have a much better saw than the 361. the 359 ported will cut circles around a stock 361, and you will have about the same money in it.
 
361

A 361 with no mid range needs the carb richened, very possibly intrnally.
my customers are very happy with the 361, but it should not be compred to a 440 size saw. We are talking apples and oranges then.
 
Wow, dragged up that old thread.... Do quick seach - someone just posted the Stihl prices from the East Coast a few days ago. The 441 runs about $30 more then a 440; the 440 will be gone in a couple of months or so..
 
Umm

Ok, when it comes down to it, there's a couple questions we need to find out. If your new to sawing stuff up, then you probably don't have a heavy hand trying to twist those dogs off. If your not and your an old saw dude or been doing it for a while, then your probably used to really getting into the raw torque. Depends. Your style of cutting should be your main focus when you decide what you want to purchase. You in a rush or do you just sit back and wait for the saw to cut it up? The answer to the questions are as follows: If you just sit back and let the saw do the job, a Husky is right for you. I've run the 372XP on more than one occasion and have really liked it, seems that the antivibe in husky's is almost unbeatable. It's got good mid range power, but like other huskys, is a dog when you put any pressure on it, I also don't like how flimsy they feel, I think the springs or whatever do that, feels like it's going to break in half. Cuts fast, I never hear anything bad about'em and from what I'm told they are pretty reliable. Had a buddy run over one with a skidder, he finished out the day with it with the top part hanging off, lol. If you tend to lean into the wood at all, you'll wanna go with a 440 or a 460. I'm cutting all kinds of stuff with my 044, same thing as the 440. From limbing to cutting 40" hard maple and Beech, it does the job and never hesitates. I've got a heavy hand, it's a bad habit I'm trying to break. I rarely ever hear anyone say anything bad about the 44's either. Everyone I know into logging in this area has at least one of these buggers in use. They use'em for felling, bucking and limbing. I used one a couple years ago and was thoroughly impressed. When I just got mine, I was disappointed. My own fault really, bad gas and bad plug. What a cutting fiend of a saw I found out it is. I've run from Stihl 020's(2.2hp) up to Stihl 066's(7hp). Been cutting wood for nearly 20 yrs now since I was a boy working in the family sawmill and the 044 made me think about what a beast Stihl had put out with this little bugger, it actually made me nervous for a little while and I've been cut with a chainsaw about 4 times now so I don't get nervous to easily. It's fast, tons of torque, revs extremely quick, relatively light, just under 14lbs, which is about 2lbs lighter than the saws I was used to running, and I'd put this baby up against anything out there in its class. I made a small muffler mod, just to open'er up a bit, and have been running it this way for about 2 weeks now without a hitch. If you decide you want more Umph! you can buy a big bore kit for only $100 and put it up to over 6hp easily and do it yourself right at home. It's probably the best investment in a saw I've ever made and when it dies, IF it ever dies, I'll put the big bore kit on it and keep using it. Good luck with what you decide eh? Hope it helps...:cheers:
 
ciscoguy01 said:
Ok, when it comes down to it, there's a couple questions we need to find out. If your new to sawing stuff up, then you probably don't have a heavy hand trying to twist those dogs off. If your not and your an old saw dude or been doing it for a while, then your probably used to really getting into the raw torque. Depends. Your style of cutting should be your main focus when you decide what you want to purchase. You in a rush or do you just sit back and wait for the saw to cut it up? The answer to the questions are as follows: If you just sit back and let the saw do the job, a Husky is right for you. I've run the 372XP on more than one occasion and have really liked it, seems that the antivibe in husky's is almost unbeatable. It's got good mid range power, but like other huskys, is a dog when you put any pressure on it, I also don't like how flimsy they feel, I think the springs or whatever do that, feels like it's going to break in half. Cuts fast, I never hear anything bad about'em and from what I'm told they are pretty reliable. Had a buddy run over one with a skidder, he finished out the day with it with the top part hanging off, lol. If you tend to lean into the wood at all, you'll wanna go with a 440 or a 460. I'm cutting all kinds of stuff with my 044, same thing as the 440. From limbing to cutting 40" hard maple and Beech, it does the job and never hesitates. I've got a heavy hand, it's a bad habit I'm trying to break. I rarely ever hear anyone say anything bad about the 44's either. Everyone I know into logging in this area has at least one of these buggers in use. They use'em for felling, bucking and limbing. I used one a couple years ago and was thoroughly impressed. When I just got mine, I was disappointed. My own fault really, bad gas and bad plug. What a cutting fiend of a saw I found out it is. I've run from Stihl 020's(2.2hp) up to Stihl 066's(7hp). Been cutting wood for nearly 20 yrs now since I was a boy working in the family sawmill and the 044 made me think about what a beast Stihl had put out with this little bugger, it actually made me nervous for a little while and I've been cut with a chainsaw about 4 times now so I don't get nervous to easily. It's fast, tons of torque, revs extremely quick, relatively light, just under 14lbs, which is about 2lbs lighter than the saws I was used to running, and I'd put this baby up against anything out there in its class. I made a small muffler mod, just to open'er up a bit, and have been running it this way for about 2 weeks now without a hitch. If you decide you want more Umph! you can buy a big bore kit for only $100 and put it up to over 6hp easily and do it yourself right at home. It's probably the best investment in a saw I've ever made and when it dies, IF it ever dies, I'll put the big bore kit on it and keep using it. Good luck with what you decide eh? Hope it helps...:cheers:

Interesting post there. I was just reading another thread about not being able to put any pressure on a 346XP. I've never messed much with Husky's but is that the norm with them??
 

Latest posts

Back
Top