Story time...pretty crazy.

Arborist Forum

Help Support Arborist Forum:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.

Nik_Danger

ArboristSite Lurker
Joined
Jun 10, 2007
Messages
39
Reaction score
2
Location
Dallas, Texas
All right there once was a little girl named...no this is not one of those stories.

Right now I am building 2 outdoor kitchens for a friend of mines stepfather. He is a senior parter for a large law firm in Dallas. He mainly represents GM, Toyota, Homedepot and other large corporate entities....blah blah. I have always noticed that he has a rather large collection of pro grade stihl chainsaws in his barns, he is a suit and tie guy at work but a real roughneck outside of the office. We have cleared many acres together with just his 044 and a john deere skidder on the weekends. Anyway I asked him when he bought his saws and he kinda looked at me with a smirk and said "I didn't pay anything for those saws". As it turns out he is a defense attorney for Stihl, and each saw was evidence in an accident lawsuit. Thats the backgound here is the story to the 044, if you guys like I will post the stories related to his 038, 026, and 046 saws later. BTW it might make you feel good that he has never defended Stihl for a product malfunction, only stupid mistakes made by the operator.


THE 044: So this guy located in east texas was felling some yellow pine...alone. One of those idiot people that shouldn't have a saw in the first place. According to Wayne, (the attorney) the guy had no idea how to fall a tree. There was no notch just multiple cuts in all of his work. He was apparently trying to cut down this one pine but it wouldn't fall. Wayne said the thing was riddled with cuts but nothing was really offsetting the weight. So instead of pulling the tree down he just decided to work on another tree behind him. As he went through the same stupid ass technique and procedure on the opposite tree the one that would not fall fell directly on him from behind. According to Wayne, numerous tree falling accidents happen just from the fact that most people have no idea how much a tree weighs so they don't respect it and it kills most of the people that get unlucky. This guy didn't die. But he was knocked unconscious. This is where he got unlucky...besides the tree falling on his dumbass he fell directly on top of his saw. The saw died when he let go but the muffler was still hot. The poor bastards face was smashed up against the muffler for well over 2 hours until someone came to his aid. It completely cooked his face and sinuses. He lived and sued Stihl. He lost and part of the settlement was that the defense attorney got to keep the evidence. I later asked Wayne if it creeped him out that his piece of equip. was involved in carnage. He looked at me and said, "no, its a good saw". I've used that saw for many many hours...and I won't use it again. It creeps me out. Not all of the stories are accidents, they do all involve people getting cut, but there are some crazy twists and each saw tells a story. I used to depend on his saws for my timber production, now I am buying my own. No bad karma here!
The 026 is the real kicker.
 
Last edited:
Nice story. I can't imagine that the guy was sueing Stihl for his own stupidity. Guess he won't be buying another Stihl or other chainsaw.
Let's hear the other stories ;)


PS. By the way, the victim, by chance, would he have a nickname called Woody, or Newguy, or somethin ??? :hmm3grin2orange: :hmm3grin2orange:
 
wow

How can someone even think of sueing Stihl(or saw co.) for that reason? How can he think that the saw caused all of that?

What would have been cool is if the 044 had a dual port muffler and that slot was imprinted into his face, like a tattoo:biggrinbounce2:
 
Nice story. I can't imagine that the guy was sueing Stihl for his own stupidity. Guess he won't be buying another Stihl or other chainsaw.
Let's hear the other stories ;)


PS. By the way, the victim, by chance, would he have a nickname called Woody, or Newguy, or somethin ??? :hmm3grin2orange: :hmm3grin2orange:

Happens all the time. Bell Helmets was repeatedly sued by people who had never owned a Bell helmet or not wearing one at all. The US legal system needs an overhaul.

Mark
 
Good story. I wouldn't mind hearing the others when you get time to type them.
 
With some people, it always has to be someone else's fault. Admiting it was their screw up would put a ding in their ego I guess
 
I wouldn't even think twice about using a saw that has mamed/killed some dope. Wasn't the saw's fault that guy wanted to make out with the saw's muffler. Kudos to the lawyer for taking his saw away from him too.

Belgian, my very first thought was this must be a bio about Newguy18. :hmm3grin2orange:
 
I'd like to hear the other stories too! You know, If chainsaw manufacturers did'nt have to deal with these stupid lawsuits the saws would probably be a whole lot cheaper............... Matt
 
026 Story

Any chance that Wayne has some nice photos (but suitable for AS) of the carnage for posting here?

no, but I always thought the saw had creosote dripped all over the cutting face...he says its blood. I can take a pic of the saw next time I see him =)

The 026: The owner of the saw was a plastic reconstructive surgeon. He owned a hospital in Mesquite, Texas. I grew up in Mesquite and know that hospital...if I got shot I would get in my car and drive to Dallas to avoid that place. Anyhow he owned the hospital and the land across and adjacent to the hospital facility. He was cutting down a mesquite tree with the saw when he claimed he slipped and the saw cut about 3/8ths of an inch into the palm of his hand. Only deep enough to cut a few tendons. Wayne (the attorney) has spent countless hours with the engineers and staff at Stihl. If there is a person that knows the reality of chainsaw accidents it is him. According to Wayne when chainsaw accidents happen to people who aren't wearing PPE, the limb or god forbid head that contacts the chain is usually severed or in the case of a head...well you're dead. For the chain to go only 3/8ths inch into his palm seemed highly unlikely. They did accident reconstruction tests based on the surgeons testimony...who by the way was suing Stihl. Sorry I didn't make that clear earlier. Stihl and the defense couldn't prove that the accident the surgeon had was negligible, just that what he was doing was accident prone. All said and done the lawsuit never went anywhere due to the fact that the saw didn't malfunction. The kicker to the whole story is this. ya know how people like Tina Turner and J Lo have insurance policies on the legs or ass...well this guy had insurance on his hands. A 56 million dollar Lloyd's policy...he cashed in on every penny. How an organization fit to insure a person's hands for that much money could open themselves up to so much vulnerability is beyond me! He faked the whole thing and cut himself!
The important part of this is that the info about severed limbs and what not is straight from Stihl's independent research. So buy some freakin chaps if you don't already wear em and keep clear of the blade from kickback. Wayne said I would be amazed at how many people die every year from chainsaw accidents.

I'll try and get some pics of the saws. He uses em so much that I doubt any blood will be visible, but I swear I remember seeing stuff cooked on that 044.
 
The Maori (native people of NZ) can be superstitious. I got an 066 from a family whose son died in a logging accident while using the saw. This made the saw some sort of Tapu (sacred) so none of the family or friends wanted anything to do with it. I got a motorbike years back the same way.
If his spirit is with the saw, he was a hard working guy.
 
All that time in the woods you thought you smelled BBQ.

Lawsuits in the USA amaze me. How many law-suits are being filed against weapons manufacturers for crack-heads shooting each other? People being too stupid to look behind them is why riding mowers all have to have reverse mowing systems. It's nuts.

I agree, good stories. Love the Darwin Awards!!!!!
 
i need to become an attorney, so i can make enought money to afford a skidder and play around with it rather that having to work it to make money

just like not requiring motorcycle helmets is a Motorcyclist's Natural Selection an idiot with a chainsaw pretty much works the same way
 
Last edited:

Latest posts

Back
Top