Last Chuck I took down was with a 130gr. 270 soft point, I think I hit the shed too. Oh well, I was renting, lol.
Yeah, I'd prefer to take them with a good varmint cartridge like a .22-250 or even a .223 because the .17HMR just doesn't have the extra distance. I'm extra cautious because there are neighbors on one side of the property.
Here in western PA I also must be careful not to shoot Phil because he provides a great excuse to get up at the crack of dawn and start drinking!