BWalker, Your point is well taken, and, of course, is cogent. Mine is that as long as the product one uses is adequate, that's probably good enough...I bet many chain saws, bikes, trimmers, snowmobiles, etc. are "blown" because of issues not directly related to the oil used, unless you take into account no oil at all.
Your experience sounds as if some of it may be related to high-perf. bike applications, where extra-duty products give enough extra margin of safety as to be very useful. I tip my hat...I played around with a lot of sno-mo engines, a few bike engines, and one Yamaha Kart; about the time I was able to get specific outputs up where we were competitive, reliability went out the window.
I've not only stuck pistons, I've broken them, melted the tops out, grenaded bottom ends, and even blown jugs off of crankcases. I doubt if I can attribute any of it to the wrong oil, but I can probably say we were trying too hard to get BMEP higher than engine components could handle.
Many of the older sno-mo engines were rehashed stationary power unit designs, not expected to hold together at 350% of their rated load.