I'm having someone come out today from Lawn Care Distributors where I bought the CB from (
http://www.lawncaredistributors.com). I brought him up to date with the knowledge that was shared here and he believes as well it's either the pump or HX but leaning more towards the pump. I'll shadow him today just to build my own confidence in servicing this thing in the future should this happen again - and keep a spare pump on hand. I have a spare solenoid, temp controller/probe so might as well have the Taco 009 on-hand also.
I do test the water, maybe not as regularly as I should but last time I did was last summer. Before that, maybe 4-5 years prior was last time I checked it.
I am in the York County area as well.