There is also a wider metal starter pawl replacement kit, 94258. On either kit the instructions say to pry the old pawl pins out but I have not had much success in getting the old ones out. If I know a saw is going to be used with the all plastic starter drum I try to find a flywheel with either the plastic or the wide metal pawls.
This style of starter pawl should only be used with the original plastic/metal clutch starter drum.
View attachment 955975
This style starter drum, preferably one that is not cracked or that has been reinforced.
View attachment 955976
These are one type of the wide metal pawls.
View attachment 955974
This is a more common retrofit metal starter pawl for use with the all plastic starter drums.
View attachment 955977
This is a flywheel with the latest plastic starter pawls.
View attachment 955978
Also keep in mind that somewhere along the way McCulloch changed the key and keyway from a standard 1/8" wide to a narrow 1/16" wide. You have to be sure your crankshaft and flywheel agree if you try to swap them around to find the right drum/pawl combination.
View attachment 955979
Mark