I could be wrong, but that SDC-80 might have the high speed check valve - 86523? If they get stiff/curl in the pocket, they will pull air into the idle circuit when coming down off throttle. Symptoms would be intermittent high idle or slow to idle down. Different reed properties could have changed the dynamics/response of that check valve.
I had to swap one on an xl-76 a couple of years ago. Did everything possible, but in the end, that was the issue.
Just a random thought if the carb does have the high speed check.