Try tilting the rails/mill - like this.
CS Milling 101, Hints tips and tricks
- Thread starter BobL
- Start date
Help Support Arborist Forum:
StihlPotlicker
ArboristSite Operative
I don't think the winch would have influenced it, but maybe it could have.
StihlPotlicker
ArboristSite Operative
ok thanks. is that a hand throttle I am seeing?
Look here for full details - https://www.arboristsite.com/threads/modding-the-bil-mill-to-take-the-880.87987/#post-1369623
Dont just look at the the first few pictures - keep scrolling.
I caught myself questioning a few things about my comment ; Mostly the nose rising not the complete back rail My way of thinking would have the saw diving down the whole width of cut, not bar nose only.
I should have edited in my thoughts .. Maybe this way will help others analyze issues on their project.
My bar nose tends to lift if the mill is only three foot or the bar is less than a 42". Always seem to have a bucket around or chunk of wood to punch out and set on the post. That generally evens out the load and using a block to hook up the winch rope when needed.
About ready to start stepping away from the saw to watch it go. The saws are quite capable of running downhill on their own.
About ready to start stepping away from the saw to watch it go. The saws are quite capable of running downhill on their own.
thenne1713
ArboristSite Guru
I cud b wrong, but my suspicion is the upper cutters are slightly longer than the lower cutters? Alternate might b that just a FEW cutters on top are longer. Do a close inspection after you note the issue? Good Luck
Hey BobL, thanks again for compiling and igniting this thread. I managed to get a beautiful finish on this cut re ently. I'm a bit rusty, but this restoked my enjoyment in the process. The knowledge and experience you share certainly helps those of us with less know-how to dive in!
Much as I felt I'd learned from Bob in years past, I found a lot I'd never actually put into practice. Had left this forum for awhile as Bob got quiet on it and posts went to a trickle, but the Facebook CSM group I joined has proved a bit disappointing after high initial hopes for it and a bit of knowledge gained. Someone on the group showed a Hi-Lift log jack device I liked that I realized looking back at the AS archives was just a copy of Bob's jack, and promptly made one of my own out of shop scrap. Got me looking at all Bob's devices and suggestions again. I like his Unistrut rail guide too, I was planning on putting one together with the same threaded rod rungs and hadn't thought of just aligning and joining extra sections like he does for long cuts. Most people just use Unistrut for first cuts propped on end brackets, so don't bother joining the rails like a ladder, but I want a rigid ladder-like structure for every cut. My cheap ladder flexes way too much. I only looked at Unistrut in person for the first time at Home Depot this week, and never realized how incredibly heavy duty it was. Would have switched to it long ago had I known. Also have gotten enthusiastically into lo pro gear and milling for most logs under 30" lately. There's literally a great companion book of more modern knowledge and devices and techniques to Malloff's "Chainsaw Lumbermaking" that could be compiled from all of Bob's posts on here.
Thanks George. I left FB about a year ago actually I have been blocked from using it by FB, but that suits me. When I joined FB I was getting lots of ads for sleazy women so I registered as a female but then to put up with ads for feminine hygiene products, so I started using FB with an ad strripper app called Fluff Buster which FB don't like. I also made lots of derogatory remarks about FB on FB until finally blokes me and they asked me for a security check - photo of me from my passport or drivers license. I declined and I have never been back. I use FB mainly to stay in touch with overseas friends an relatives but we now use private chat apps for that so I dont miss FB at all.
Back to your topic. I have thought about writing a a book. Maybe when I can no longer use a big CS?
Back to your topic. I have thought about writing a a book. Maybe when I can no longer use a big CS?
Yeah, I'd never survive FB without FluffBuster - even then FB has tried every way they can to make parts of FluffBuster not work. A number of my friends have had all kinds of drama with FB if they've alarmed any of the AI bots by saying the wrong thing. I kind of have to use it as a marketing tool cause I'm an author/historian as well as a woodworker, but was perfectly happy before FB came along and am sure could be perfectly happy without it. Write that book someday! But I hear ya, I keep too busy milling and woodworking to write most of the time cause there's just no money in writing and I can do it all I want when I can no longer pick up a chainsaw. Actually have 16 hectares north of Bundaberg in QLD that I bought for my Dad 36 years ago that I haven't been to in 30 years. Was all scrappy smaller gum trees back then but maybe there's something worth milling there by now. It's ironic that all the information at people's fingertips there is these days, this long history of milling info to be mined here and other sites, and the vast amount of new millers are still crawling around on the ground trying to figure out why their chains don't cut better. Not enough curiosity and desire to work smarter not harder. Partly I think that's the China clone effect of all things milling - you can buy a cheap clone saw, mill, chain, etc, so a lot of new guys haven't had to figure out the first thing of building/tweaking/fixing anything themselves. My proudest moment in the past five years was fabricating my own industrial strength 20 ton shop press from the ground up. All American steel from the local steel recycling yard, 2 x 3 rectangular tubing and 4 x 5/8" steel flat bar, and Ford 351 bolts from a dead engine I dismantled. Absolutely bombproof. The Chinese frames bend with like 5 tons of pressure. Every single Chinese product I've found fault with has usually been not to do with the precision of machining, it's always been the incredibly low strength of Chinese steel.
My take on Bob's Hi-Lift log jack, based on shop scraps. For the triangle stabilizer, some 1.5" aluminum angle I had left over from first attempts at a frame for a router sled setup (proved too flexible over a span). The attachment is a cut down section from a first attempt at a cross member for a home built shop press that I decided wasn't strong enough. I bent a couple scrap pieces of 2 x 1/4 flat bar in my shop press bender and bolted them on to the attachment. Then I figured out I couldn't just balance the attachment on the jack, so I ran a U bolt through the tubing to secure it.
Attachments
On to "pimp my mill" upgrades long overdue. My CBB (can’t be bothered) always got in the way. Was spurred along by getting a GB lo pro bar that had already been drilled for an oiler bolt and came w one, and also had bar holes for bolt on mounting. Drilled holes in the upper clamps w a 17/64 bit, tapped it to 5/16 thread, and now have easy chain replacement while still in the mill, and can cut lower. Put together my PVC pipe aux oiler. And switched out my clunky larger winch I'd just used cause I already had it to the smallest cheapest 600lb winch I could find ($20-ish on Amazon). Finally the milling setup I’ve always wanted. All my GB bars are pre-drilled for bolt on, just need to drill my 42” Stihl .404 bar. Now I have the clamp bolt holes free on the mill, I can run wheel setups through them. There's been the knock on the standard Granberg accessory that it's only good for the top half of the log, which Bob compensated for on his custom setup by making his wheels adjustable height, but still always below the bar (I stand corrected on that, as Bob points out below). While messing around with spacers on my bolts to keep the wheels fixed at a lower position, I thought, why not put wheels on the top side as well - four wheel drive lol. These are small old skate wheels, minimal diameter, but I have rollerblade wheels twice as wide I can try too if they prove better for wildly uneven logs. May be some flaw in my thinking here, but seems it should be a good cheap simple wheel guide solution. Can take them off easily when I do last cuts where I want the bar as low as possible (a good feature of bolt on vs clamping).
Attachments
I’ve been lurking here for a while reading as much as I can. I’ve been chainsaw milling for about 4 years now, with the last couple being more serious. I don’t have much to add except for some of my recent modifications and builds for and adjacent to milling. I’ve seen the many options posted here for first cut rails (what many call log rails). I don’t claim that this is the best, I just want to present an option that may be interesting, and I am very happy with how things turned out.
I decided to get some v-slot 2020 based aluminum extrusion and accessories to build with. I bought 2m lengths of 2020, 2040, and 2080.
For my first cut rail, I used 2040 vertically oriented, and two sections linked end to end, which gives me a total length right around 13 ft. The cross members are also 2040 horizontally oriented with holes drilled for my screws. I also added a middle rail of 2020 that matches my beam mill so I can double purpose the rail for both the first cut and for perpendicular beam cuts when needed.
I also used the aluminum to build a router sled for flattening the slabs, primarily out of 2020 with a ½” acrylic base plate and v-wheels that sit in the v-slot. I built a cross rail that matched the width of the wheels:
I just recently decided to add gantry plates with wheels that also match the v-slots:
This essentially allows my cross rail to act as a linear rail, and I can add more rails on end to make it longer if needed. I had originally thought the 2080 would be wide enough, but for my thicker slabs, I needed to add more aluminum. I do plan on buying more aluminum, and adding some 2060 to give myself more flexibility.
It was expensive to get all the aluminum and the fittings, but it did exactly what I’ve been wanting to be able to do, and I’ll be getting more to keep on hand to build more fixtures and jigs, as it is really versatile for these things.
I hope this gives some of you ideas of what you can do and build with!
I decided to get some v-slot 2020 based aluminum extrusion and accessories to build with. I bought 2m lengths of 2020, 2040, and 2080.
For my first cut rail, I used 2040 vertically oriented, and two sections linked end to end, which gives me a total length right around 13 ft. The cross members are also 2040 horizontally oriented with holes drilled for my screws. I also added a middle rail of 2020 that matches my beam mill so I can double purpose the rail for both the first cut and for perpendicular beam cuts when needed.
I also used the aluminum to build a router sled for flattening the slabs, primarily out of 2020 with a ½” acrylic base plate and v-wheels that sit in the v-slot. I built a cross rail that matched the width of the wheels:
I just recently decided to add gantry plates with wheels that also match the v-slots:
This essentially allows my cross rail to act as a linear rail, and I can add more rails on end to make it longer if needed. I had originally thought the 2080 would be wide enough, but for my thicker slabs, I needed to add more aluminum. I do plan on buying more aluminum, and adding some 2060 to give myself more flexibility.
It was expensive to get all the aluminum and the fittings, but it did exactly what I’ve been wanting to be able to do, and I’ll be getting more to keep on hand to build more fixtures and jigs, as it is really versatile for these things.
I hope this gives some of you ideas of what you can do and build with!
I've had topside wheels on BIL since 2009?
White Teflon ones adjustable height ones above the bar and Black HDPE below the bar.
20On my small mill the wheels can be rotated to be either above or blow the bar.
Sorry, my bad, Bob, I've usually just caught your early versions of things going through threads and you tend to be three steps ahead of me with your final advanced versions. Or also sometimes I skim too fast and don't fully absorb what you've done in the first place. Really top notch system.
Excellent setup - I've always thought thought you could build some of the best setups with that but never yet been willing to commit the time and money to do so. I was thinking for my next router planing setup of doing something more like a manual version of a CNC router. Same rails and adjustable height router mount as CNC, just you move it around. People are doing it but with conventional flat cross sleds rather than raised bridges like CNC machines. Only downside to the bridge mount is I can only mount my Bosch 2 1/4 hp router rather than my 3 1/4 in the CNC router housing. My desire for a raised bridge like on a CNC versus everyone else's manual router sled designs I've seen with CNC rails is most people are limited to milling slabs in the 2-4" range unless they put risers under their rails to do thicker pieces which seems an extra bother. Which is fine for most people because that's all their doing is slabs that size, but I want to have a wide range of thicknesses I can easily adjust to do from 1-6".
No worries George.
Yeah, I've been thinking about this for a long time, but the cost always made me hesitant - I spent $800 to get everything that I felt I needed and to have enough extras just in case. I also intend on spending another $700ish to add more capability and options for the future, but I do feel comfortable with that now that I've seen what I can do with the material and the fittings.
What you say is true about adding height for the rails for thicker slabs. It is actually pretty easy with this aluminum extrusion though, as there are three hole plates that line up with the v slots to line them up easily, which is what I had to do for the slab that I was working on in the picture - I had to add 2040 to the 2080 to get the thickness I needed. There are other fittings that make connecting the rails on end pretty easy too, so with the 2m sections, if I need more length, I can pretty easily add as much as I want.
For the gantry style, I'd be concerned with racking and stability while moving. Were you thinking of an acme thread for the z axis movement?
Nice work on the Al rails.
When I made my log rails out of HD Unistrut back in 2007 I looked into using Al extrusions but the cost was more than twice that for the Unistrut and I had no idea how they would stand up to the weight. Now that I'm heading into my late 60's my knees would no longer like me repeatedly lifting those HD Unistruts iso a set of Al rails sounds more and more appealing but I cant justify them as I hardly ever use my big CS mills these days.
Your design could be modified by adding adjustable width and brackets that grab the end of the log like this.
The bolts have pointed ends which bite into the log end hold the rails very firmly.
When I made my log rails out of HD Unistrut back in 2007 I looked into using Al extrusions but the cost was more than twice that for the Unistrut and I had no idea how they would stand up to the weight. Now that I'm heading into my late 60's my knees would no longer like me repeatedly lifting those HD Unistruts iso a set of Al rails sounds more and more appealing but I cant justify them as I hardly ever use my big CS mills these days.
Your design could be modified by adding adjustable width and brackets that grab the end of the log like this.
The bolts have pointed ends which bite into the log end hold the rails very firmly.
Similar threads
Latest posts
-
-
Shot my Oak Sapling, Long Story... Will it survive?- Latest: Mad Professor
-
-
-
-
Sponsors' stores or best places to buy Bars, Chains, etc.
- Latest: EchoShindaiwaMakitaDolmar
-
-
Scrounging Firewood (and other stuff)- Latest: MustangMike