Electric Chainsaws???

Arborist Forum

Help Support Arborist Forum:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.
I've got the husky 316e. It gets the job done. Definitely not fast.
As far as peak hp, most companies rate it by measuring the amp draw when the tool is stalled and converting it. It means nothing about real world use. It's basically startup current on the motor.
 
As far as peak hp, most companies rate it by measuring the amp draw when the tool is stalled and converting it. It means nothing about real world use. It's basically startup current on the motor.
Doesn't a stalled collector motor short circuit and thus draw theoretically unlimited current causing either the motor to burn up or the hopefully correct wall socket fuse to pop?
I might be wrong, just saying.

I have a wall socket current meter and some of the power tools I tested showed higher then rated current upon start-up , lower then rated current once running without load , and about the rated current running under load.
When the electric power tool is being overloaded it will draw much higher then rated current and heat up quickly - what brings us back to the motor stalling point.

All electric power tools I have feature mono phase/220 Volt collector motors.

An electric chainsaw features higher torque then a similarly kW rated 2-stroke chainsaw and it pretty much runs at a constant rpm.
I grew up with a Sachs-Dolmar 285 electric saw rated 1300W and a Sachs-Dolmar 105 2-stroke saw rated 1.7 kW (40cc).
The 105 does feature higher chain speed due to higher rpm's , but I clearly remember that the 285 had the upper hand on torque and could be pushed much harder (being the cause of the plastic housing giving up during hours of log bucking).
Both where set up with the same interchangeable bar & chain combo, 3/8" Low Profile safety chain & 14" bar.

I for one would not mind having a running electric saw again as I find myself often pulling out my PS-6400 to cut stuff the deceased 285 would have handled equally well.
Once I hopefully successfully reassemble my little 105 I will have a "small" saw for any odd quick jobs and/or cutting small stuff where the PS-6400/7900 are just pure overkill.

Electric chainsaws are cool power tools , as long as one doesn't expect them to perform like a ported 90+cc 2-stroke chainsaw! ;)
 
For example:
I just looked up a ridgid shop vac sold at Home Depot.
Rated as:
5 HP
120v/10a
10amps at 120v is 1200 watt. Divided by 746 watts per HP = 1.6 HP
To achieve the rated 5HP it needs to draw 31 amps. This can be done by stalling the motor, and yes at this point it should trip the breaker.
It only works on paper, because 746 watts equals 1hp they can claim 5 hp if they can get that motor to draw 31amps or use 3700+ watts.
 
Also another side point about hp ratings.
If replacing a gas powered motor with electric, because the gas motors have large hp/torque curves and electric are much straighter, sizing is roughly 1/2 the hp for the electric replacement.
 
My luck if I tried to fell a tree with electric, I would get caught up on the cord and trip as I backed out lol

Sent from my SM-G920V using Tapatalk
 
Now to add a spin on electric and firewood, I had purchased that homelite electric 5ton splitter from the HD, Now that thing was convenient and quiet. I could take some splits out in the garage and fiddle them down to some great sized kindling at any time with out disturbing a mouse. Sold it after I bought my beast that I now have to wear ear protection with.

Sent from my SM-G920V using Tapatalk
 
That is pretty cool. I think it works so well because of the thin splitter wedge. Watch the video of the owner just going at it like it's a race. His back must of felt great the next morning!

Sent from my SM-G920V using Tapatalk
 
Uh oh, you just said that an electric saw compares equally to a gas saw, those are fighting words. Lol

Sent from my SM-G920V using Tapatalk
 
Makita UC4000 versus Husqvarna 562XP
62cc wins!

I usually cut smaller stuff than that with my electric, but occasionally cut bigger wood.

I love my UC4000. Should also point out that it is 13 Amps and has been replaced by a newer model, that I believe is 15 Amps.

And, just to stir the pot further for the traditionalists, I run PowerSharp chain on mine!

Makita Noodling PowerSharp.jpg

Philbert
 
Back
Top