Sawyer Rob
Addicted to ArboristSite
Your story makes me wonder why the famous bear guide, Phil Shoemaker also recommends either 200 NP's or 220 NP's, your choice, in 30 cal., and has no problem with someone showing up to camp with a 30-06? He says it's a most reliable bullet, too. Phil is a great guy and a great Alaskan bear guide, you must know him, if not you should try to catch up with him, he's a wealth of bear hunting knowledge. Ask him about him killing a fairly big charging brown bear with his 9mm pistol! lolSounds good We can definitely agree to disagree. I've heard a lot of horror stories from fellow hunters and Guides stop using the NP because of severe bullet segmentation when hitting big bone. Thus not penatrating into the vitals. IMOP its an older design and there are better projectiles on the market today. The fact that a 180 out of an 06 on a Blacktial separated on light bone and didn't punch through the entire animal was enough to make me a non believer , and that was just medium game. I Shot both my Kodiak's with 250gr Swift A-frames out of a .338WM first bear took only one shot and the game was over. Dropped in his tracks dead. The second bear only took two doses of the bullet. Both well placed shots breaking heavy bone and penatrating deep through vitals and breaking heavy bone on the other side only to stop short of the hide. All the bullets energy was used inside both animals. No energy wasted by over penatrating or rapid segmentation. Like I said earlier, A favorite amongst African PH's. However, it sounds like the NP has worked well for you Pard, and thats all that matters right? Whatever works for you. The Swift A-frame definitely works for me!
I've shot and have seen shot my share of big bears, also other big animals like moose, and had the chance to see how a number of different bullets work, used by hunters I took out, and I've got nothing but good things to say about NP's, they work very well in the biggest big game and still better than the others in smaller animals, making them the best all-around bullet available.
SR