Treespotter
ArboristSite Operative
[emoji1]
Cordless Chainsaws and Outdoor Power Equipment
Help Support Arborist Forum:
zemmo
ArboristSite Operative
Just checkin' in. No sign of the brushless Oregon? I see they have an 80V saw now. It may be that they're chasing voltage numbers to no advantage, like they used to do with pixels in digital cameras. We'll see. My firewood season is over for the year, but I'll probably buy one next fall. Keep up the posts, y'all.
Due out 'this summer'.
Good point on voltage. We tend to associate more volts with more power, but the real test is how they perform.
Philbert
zemmo
ArboristSite Operative
'Twould make more sense to rate the batteries in watt/hrs, and to let us know the motor wattage as well. I see that both Tesla and Nissan (Leaf) have configured their battery packs at 360 VDC nominal, for what it's worth.
Apparently the European markets rate their batteries differently. And there is the business of '36 volt' and '40 volt' batteries really being the same, but measured differently. It would be nice to have uniform standards. But again, the numbers are only part of the story. Just like some 5occ saws outperform some 55cc saws.
I am more impressed with the larger capacities of the batteries, which increase usable run time. From 1.25AHr, to 2.4, to 4.0 becoming standard. I have seen some 6.0 AHr batteries as well. I don't know what the practical limitations are; I would not want to carry around one of those large backpack batteries, due to the weight. Not sure if the fire hazards of Lithium-ion batteries increases with the size either - we tend to think of battery saws as 'safer', because they don't store flammable fuels, but some batteries have their own issues.
Philbert
I am more impressed with the larger capacities of the batteries, which increase usable run time. From 1.25AHr, to 2.4, to 4.0 becoming standard. I have seen some 6.0 AHr batteries as well. I don't know what the practical limitations are; I would not want to carry around one of those large backpack batteries, due to the weight. Not sure if the fire hazards of Lithium-ion batteries increases with the size either - we tend to think of battery saws as 'safer', because they don't store flammable fuels, but some batteries have their own issues.
Philbert
zemmo
ArboristSite Operative
Ohm's law is international. The nominal voltage of nearly all these Li-ion cells is 3.7, though a freshly charged cell would be higher. A 2Ahr 80 volt (74V) battery pack has the same capacity and weight as a 4Ahr, 40 volt (37V) pack, measured in Whr. I don't want a huge battery, and it's important to keep the weight of the saw+battery down. I don't plan to use a saw like this to make noodles ;^} I think around 150Whr is my preferred max for weight. Although if the cells keep gaining capacity, as they have been, that could increase. I think Tesla has proven that even enormous Li-ion packs can be safe enough for consumer use.
Well, a Tesla, Prius, or Leaf, and a long extension cord, might be part of a nice scrounging package!
(I know that some of the ham radio guys already think of these vehicles as 'rolling battery packs).
Philbert
zemmo
ArboristSite Operative
Yeah, if they'd come out with a 400 volt saw, you wouldn't even have to step down the voltage!
Treespotter
ArboristSite Operative
120 volts first!
Later this week we get the 5120 LiXP in for some serious testing.
Later this week we get the 5120 LiXP in for some serious testing.
- Joined
- Jan 11, 2014
- Messages
- 3,397
- Reaction score
- 4,033
That 5120 looks as big as a 3120. If it weighs as much, those batteries should last a long time.
Treespotter
ArboristSite Operative
It doesn't look as big as the 3120 sawfun, it is as big as a 3120! The housing is placed over the components. In the car industry this would be called a mule. Testing the technical components in a existing body. The saw in the picture is a fraction heavier than the 3120.
Is this a serious prototype? I assumed that it was a Photoshopped gag.
Philbert
Philbert
7sleeper
Addicted to ArboristSite
That's what I also thought. especially with a regular size battery how long will the cutting time last?!
7
Treespotter
ArboristSite Operative
Twelve amps is not that regular. All mine are three an for all I know the 4. something is the biggest at the moment.
Treespotter
ArboristSite Operative
It fits the same charger. Probably has to stay in there during the night. [emoji52]
7sleeper
Addicted to ArboristSite
Treespotter
ArboristSite Operative
The battery is like a Pinoccio nose. It gets longer when you add exorbitant amounts of amps.
The ECHO 58V mower has ports for two, 4.0AHr batteries, but apparently, only uses one at a time. The Makita 36V saw has an option to use two, 18V batteries in tandem, for those who have already invested in their 18V tools. Maybe we will see more dual battery tools? Interesting to see the trade offs in battery sizes, weight, run time, etc. as these tools progress.
Philbert | Philbert
Philbert | Philbert
Not a chainsaw, but this battery powered product really . . . . (well, you know)!
20 Volts, Li-Ion.
Philbert
20 Volts, Li-Ion.
Philbert
