Crappy Stihl Cylinder - Looks like ChiCom Garbage!!!

Arborist Forum

Help Support Arborist Forum:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.
O no the dog gots a new toy.

<embed width="448" height="361" type="application/x-shockwave-flash" wmode="transparent" src="http://i669.photobucket.com/player.swf?file=http://vid669.photobucket.com/albums/vv60/bookerdog/441.flv">
 
O no the dog gots a new toy.

<embed width="448" height="361" type="application/x-shockwave-flash" wmode="transparent" src="http://i669.photobucket.com/player.swf?file=http://vid669.photobucket.com/albums/vv60/bookerdog/441.flv">

Book,

That all the longer that thing would run? Wonder about that cylinder.

Huuummm,

joat
 
The doctor prescribes Midol®.......:rolleyes:

Wow. Post #808. A thread one day old. Is that a record?

I was not going to participate, but aw whut thuh heyeck.

It bugs me that Stihl is no longer using Mahle cylinders, esp. given the appearance of the one Brad posted. I have a few new Stihls, and I wish they had jugs that gave evidence of craftsmanship. I consider Stihl to be a saw for the ages, something you can give yer grandkid, who'll run it proudly long after yer departed. (If I were cuttin' palm trees in Australia, I would consider all saws disposable....)

This trend is, along with the zamachink carbs, one of which I replaced on my MS200T, saddening. I still think they are the best saws out there, but I wish they would keep the quality up. Stihl sits atop the OPE heap for a reason. I hope this isn't squandered in the name of a quick shekel. A privately held company can tell the nonexistent stockholders to go eat fruit bats. The saws will stihl sell, and the customers will appreciate the quality of a saw designed and built for the ages. Nothing sucks worse than being out in the timber with a cheap Homelite Super 2 that will not start. Ask me how I know this. In my book, it's stihl "Stihl Über Alles!"
 
Last edited:
Does Stihl say use rope, they do not, sorry Brad but thats a fact. The rope is the preferred method, the piston stop is the Stihl method, look at the results and I guess you can see why. Stick to the manual next time and you won't have bent rods and busted pistons, hell look at mine, thats using a piston stop, not rope, and gently doing it the right way..

It was wrong of me to wonder why or how you did it, my bad, but put the blame where it belongs.

Oh, the manual.......thats right......., Stihl........? the manual........? the IPL.......? Hummm......all the things Stihl wants you to pay for (or go to a dealer that has less knowledge of the products they're selling than the person trying to service them his or her self) in order to service your own equipment: You have to be a dealer or know someone who is in order to work on your own equipment because Stihl is so afraid someone can be a do-it-yourself kind of person and do just as good, if not better, of a job at fixing their equipment than the johhny-come-lately "hey I'm a Stihl dealer" that is popping up on every corner nowadays. I've got to say, Stihl missed the bus when it comes to helping out the do-it yourself guy with enough knoledge to keep them coming back and buying parts from the dealer. To me, stihl products are starting to fall into the disposable category. Thank goodness for the used parts resources & forums like this!
 
I must turn away now!

Some like the rush of watching an accident, but it just isn't me. This is the bash Stihl thread of the year, perhaps of the entire existence of AS.

I'll predict that before it's over, someone will post something to the effect of: "Andreas Stihl ran over my crippled, pregnant mother and refused to pay for her broken cane."

for every thing under the sun, there is a time .........
 
Dolmar 401 Pros & Cons
I'm thinking about replacing my MS180 with a Dolmar 401. I'm intrgued by it due to it's pro style build construction with a vertically split mag case. It's 6cc bigger at 39cc, and .3 BHP stronger at 2.3 bhp. Yet the weight is the same at 8.8 lbs. The only draw back I see is that it only turns 12,000 RPMs, a lot less than a MS180 which turns 14,000-14,500. I'm wondering if it's enough torquier that it may not actually turn that much slower in the cut though. On top of that, I may be able to get some RPMs out of it with a good port job.

More importantly, how is the build quality? Is the rod and piston more durable than what I've found in the MS180? Can you work on this thing without it breaking on you? I'd like to see a forged rod rather than a piece of stamped sheet metal!


This was Brad's post I wonder if the rod failure had anything to due with the stress that it was put under running at those rpm's. HMMMM metal fatigue, stretching being abused by being run at who knows what rpms for the sake of a few video's to show the prowess of a modded saw. I may be wrong dosen't the 401 Dolmar also use a stamped rod? Why hasn't it been called out. What does a person expect out of a inexpensive home owner saw?
15,000-16,000 rpms with no issue, think the piston might have been weakened operating at those temperatures and speeds, sure as heck wasn't designed for it, but what the hell it was a piece of crap because it failed during tear down. I feel for whoever bought that saw off trading post.
 
Woodie put your pacifier back in and stop hollering, the other kids are trying to sleep,hehe

I looked up Billy Bob Teeth's pacifiers, and I found a picture of Woody at the last fambly reunion. They evidently bleeve that there sex stuff is best kept "in the fambly..."

attachment.php


So Woody, which one are you? :greenchainsaw:
 
I don't know how much of this is just good natured humor , but B Snelling Posted some pictures and made a valid point. Look what Stihl is putting on some of their saws.

I respect Brad for doing that, and it seem some have headed off in another direction. Well how does it run? Will it cut wood?

That is subjective and hardly the point. The point is that the management at Stihl has made a decision to put second class cylinders on their saws.

Anybody believe that cylinder will run as smooth and strong?

Anybody believe that it will last as long?

Stihl management could have a sticker on top each saw. "Oh by the way, this saw does not have a Mahle cylinder, it has one made in Brazil, but don't worry, it might look like hell, but the saw will run."


It might take a while, but it will come back and bite them.

I just bought a new 361. If I find a cylinder like that in my saw, they will never sell me another saw.
 
Tom...I'm your friend. You know that. And I hope you're mine.

That said...stop dancing. Seriously. As long as you're in here looking like Andreas's puppet, people are going to be taking pot shots at you.

Stihl's ethics in this case are not defensible, and I think you know that.

But if you keep attempting to defend them, people will begin to question yours.

And I'd hate to see that happen, cause I think yours are top notch.



.


.


Dear Woodie I am not dancing , I'm calling it as I see it. I realize many can't understand how come Thall didn't come up and say hey man Stihl will take care of that like he usually does when he see's a fault. I see a fault in the cylinder, no question on that, its crappy looking. Thats probly the 10th time I've said that btw. As this thread unfolded I've seen things that appear even worse than that cylinder, much worse. None of that matters to me, the only concern and the only question that was never answered is how does the saw run. I hear that does not matter, that is not the point, since when? That is the only point of a chainsaw, how well it runs and cuts, thats it and thats all. If the flaws in that cylinder do not affect the performance of the saw there is little ground to stand on to get a replacement cylinder free of charge, especially in this case when the saw was torn apart for what, profit, not because of a running issue.

I stated before if that saw was brought in with a complaint its not running right and I tore it apart and decided that crappy looking cylinder is the problem it would be replaced at no charge with a much better looking cylinder. None of this has taken place with this saw. Once again no ground to stand on for a free cylinder.

Now to Stihl and that cylinder from Brasil. Its been said Stihl pulled a fast one. Their quality is falling off, they are getting sneaky, they are cutting cost, the list is amazing considering not one single word of it can be taken as fact when its all assumtion. We have 4 saw builders saying these things, we have Brads cylinder as proof. If everything thats been said is true then there are another 7 million crappy cylinders being shipped out this year. Most will be Mahle, the same maker other saw makers are using. Sorry Woodie but I'm not buying it because of less than a hand full of cylinders. If 20,000 bad cylinders go out this year, not crappy looking but bad, out of 7 million you may get my ear. I know the camp Husky can relish in that hand full of cylinders, I find that funny considering Stihl is in a much better position than them, and no Husky man can dispute that with they just did a few months ago. Oh thats not the point, we're talking about a crappy looking cylinder, Stihl is going downhill and on and on and when we know for a fact who is going down by way of the pink slips, like it or not thats the facts as to who is really down, not assumtions, facts.

Far as ethics go I know mine are in tact but I got to wonder about yours and others. I know how the game is played around here, I know who the players are and I know how these threads work. I enjoy them and rarely ever get serious about anything. I really don't give a hoot in hell about saws at all but they are fun to fuss over, I like it. That said don't ever think I'm going to sit back and let you have your fun and me not get mine. You know as well as me you have nothing to offer cept bash Stihl every chance you get and thats fine, Fast does the same, though I wish he would quit knocking my customers, thats low, but anyway if the name of the game is hey there's a Stihl thread going on, lets go get on Hall, and that seems to be the case bigtime with you and Fast, thats all fine and well, I love it. That said if your questioning my ethics because I too like to have fun and send the BS right back then sorry Woodie, your gonna have to accept it. Neither you or Brad or anyone is gonna keep this cat from pouring it on when its being poured on. I like to mix it up and yes I'm gonna toss in things people don't like or can't take. I was called to this thread by Fast and hey ok, I'm here. Course I woulda come calling sooner or later, I can't pass up a BS thread like this and thats exactly how I see this thread, alotta fun, alotta asumtions, a crappy looking cylinder, to that I say BFD, cry me a river and get over it, but the fun, awwwwwwwwwwwwww yes, that I like. Ethics is two fold Woodie, you want ethics, start looking at everyones ethics, not just those you chose to, DEAL? If not oh well, DISMISSED! You knew I would use your own line on you sooner or later so shush punk!!
 
Dear Woodie I am not dancing , I'm calling it as I see it. I realize many can't understand how come Thall didn't come up and say hey man Stihl will take care of that like he usually does when he see's a fault. I see a fault in the cylinder, no question on that, its crappy looking. Thats probly the 10th time I've said that btw. As this thread unfolded I've seen things that appear even worse than that cylinder, much worse. None of that matters to me, the only concern and the only question that was never answered is how does the saw run. I hear that does not matter, that is not the point, since when? That is the only point of a chainsaw, how well it runs and cuts, thats it and thats all. If the flaws in that cylinder do not affect the performance of the saw there is little ground to stand on to get a replacement cylinder free of charge, especially in this case when the saw was torn apart for what, profit, not because of a running issue.

I stated before if that saw was brought in with a complaint its not running right and I tore it apart and decided that crappy looking cylinder is the problem it would be replaced at no charge with a much better looking cylinder. None of this has taken place with this saw. Once again no ground to stand on for a free cylinder.

Now to Stihl and that cylinder from Brasil. Its been said Stihl pulled a fast one. Their quality is falling off, they are getting sneaky, they are cutting cost, the list is amazing considering not one single word of it can be taken as fact when its all assumtion. We have 4 saw builders saying these things, we have Brads cylinder as proof. If everything thats been said is true then there are another 7 million crappy cylinders being shipped out this year. Most will be Mahle, the same maker other saw makers are using. Sorry Woodie but I'm not buying it because of less than a hand full of cylinders. If 20,000 bad cylinders go out this year, not crappy looking but bad, out of 7 million you may get my ear. I know the camp Husky can relish in that hand full of cylinders, I find that funny considering Stihl is in a much better position than them, and no Husky man can dispute that with they just did a few months ago. Oh thats not the point, we're talking about a crappy looking cylinder, Stihl is going downhill and on and on and when we know for a fact who is going down by way of the pink slips, like it or not thats the facts as to who is really down, not assumtions, facts.

Far as ethics go I know mine are in tact but I got to wonder about yours and others. I know how the game is played around here, I know who the players are and I know how these threads work. I enjoy them and rarely ever get serious about anything. I really don't give a hoot in hell about saws at all but they are fun to fuss over, I like it. That said don't ever think I'm going to sit back and let you have your fun and me not get mine. You know as well as me you have nothing to offer cept bash Stihl every chance you get and thats fine, Fast does the same, though I wish he would quit knocking my customers, thats low, but anyway if the name of the game is hey there's a Stihl thread going on, lets go get on Hall, and that seems to be the case bigtime with you and Fast, thats all fine and well, I love it. That said if your questioning my ethics because I too like to have fun and send the BS right back then sorry Woodie, your gonna have to accept it. Neither you or Brad or anyone is gonna keep this cat from pouring it on when its being poured on. I like to mix it up and yes I'm gonna toss in things people don't like or can't take. I was called to this thread by Fast and hey ok, I'm here. Course I woulda come calling sooner or later, I can't pass up a BS thread like this and thats exactly how I see this thread, alotta fun, alotta asumtions, a crappy looking cylinder, to that I say BFD, cry me a river and get over it, but the fun, awwwwwwwwwwwwww yes, that I like. Ethics is two fold Woodie, you want ethics, start looking at everyones ethics, not just those you chose to, DEAL? If not oh well, DISMISSED! You knew I would use your own line on you sooner or later so shush punk!!

cripe how long it take you to type that. At least there's not to many big words in there.
 
Dear Woodie I am not dancing , I'm calling it as I see it. I realize many can't understand how come Thall didn't come up and say hey man Stihl will take care of that like he usually does when he see's a fault. I see a fault in the cylinder, no question on that, its crappy looking. Thats probly the 10th time I've said that btw. As this thread unfolded I've seen things that appear even worse than that cylinder, much worse. None of that matters to me, the only concern and the only question that was never answered is how does the saw run. I hear that does not matter, that is not the point, since when? That is the only point of a chainsaw, how well it runs and cuts, thats it and thats all. If the flaws in that cylinder do not affect the performance of the saw there is little ground to stand on to get a replacement cylinder free of charge, especially in this case when the saw was torn apart for what, profit, not because of a running issue.

I stated before if that saw was brought in with a complaint its not running right and I tore it apart and decided that crappy looking cylinder is the problem it would be replaced at no charge with a much better looking cylinder. None of this has taken place with this saw. Once again no ground to stand on for a free cylinder.

Now to Stihl and that cylinder from Brasil. Its been said Stihl pulled a fast one. Their quality is falling off, they are getting sneaky, they are cutting cost, the list is amazing considering not one single word of it can be taken as fact when its all assumtion. We have 4 saw builders saying these things, we have Brads cylinder as proof. If everything thats been said is true then there are another 7 million crappy cylinders being shipped out this year. Most will be Mahle, the same maker other saw makers are using. Sorry Woodie but I'm not buying it because of less than a hand full of cylinders. If 20,000 bad cylinders go out this year, not crappy looking but bad, out of 7 million you may get my ear. I know the camp Husky can relish in that hand full of cylinders, I find that funny considering Stihl is in a much better position than them, and no Husky man can dispute that with they just did a few months ago. Oh thats not the point, we're talking about a crappy looking cylinder, Stihl is going downhill and on and on and when we know for a fact who is going down by way of the pink slips, like it or not thats the facts as to who is really down, not assumtions, facts.

Far as ethics go I know mine are in tact but I got to wonder about yours and others. I know how the game is played around here, I know who the players are and I know how these threads work. I enjoy them and rarely ever get serious about anything. I really don't give a hoot in hell about saws at all but they are fun to fuss over, I like it. That said don't ever think I'm going to sit back and let you have your fun and me not get mine. You know as well as me you have nothing to offer cept bash Stihl every chance you get and thats fine, Fast does the same, though I wish he would quit knocking my customers, thats low, but anyway if the name of the game is hey there's a Stihl thread going on, lets go get on Hall, and that seems to be the case bigtime with you and Fast, thats all fine and well, I love it. That said if your questioning my ethics because I too like to have fun and send the BS right back then sorry Woodie, your gonna have to accept it. Neither you or Brad or anyone is gonna keep this cat from pouring it on when its being poured on. I like to mix it up and yes I'm gonna toss in things people don't like or can't take. I was called to this thread by Fast and hey ok, I'm here. Course I woulda come calling sooner or later, I can't pass up a BS thread like this and thats exactly how I see this thread, alotta fun, alotta asumtions, a crappy looking cylinder, to that I say BFD, cry me a river and get over it, but the fun, awwwwwwwwwwwwww yes, that I like. Ethics is two fold Woodie, you want ethics, start looking at everyones ethics, not just those you chose to, DEAL? If not oh well, DISMISSED! You knew I would use your own line on you sooner or later so shush punk!!

One question. Do you think its fair for two customers to pay the same for the same saw, one has Mahale, and one has a cheaper Brazil cylinder. I don't , but my 1 opinion won' amount to much to Stihl.
 
Oh, the manual.......thats right......., Stihl........? the manual........? the IPL.......? Hummm......all the things Stihl wants you to pay for (or go to a dealer that has less knowledge of the products they're selling than the person trying to service them his or her self) in order to service your own equipment: You have to be a dealer or know someone who is in order to work on your own equipment because Stihl is so afraid someone can be a do-it-yourself kind of person and do just as good, if not better, of a job at fixing their equipment than the johhny-come-lately "hey I'm a Stihl dealer" that is popping up on every corner nowadays. I've got to say, Stihl missed the bus when it comes to helping out the do-it yourself guy with enough knoledge to keep them coming back and buying parts from the dealer. To me, stihl products are starting to fall into the disposable category. Thank goodness for the used parts resources & forums like this!

Oh my look at that sig of yours and tell me why your here, let me guess, hey join the crowd buddy. Things they want you to pay for, oh my, now we got bashers who feel Stihl should give stuff away for free. A piston stop costs 2.00, wow, bud if your that hard up I'll send you one for free, naaaa, to hell with ya, make it 5.00,:hmm3grin2orange::hmm3grin2orange::hmm3grin2orange:
 

Latest posts

Back
Top