Piston vs cylinder wall is only 1/2 of the equation. If a piston seal goes you lose pressure due to by pass. ram seals cause a bit of this as well- but primarly is fluid being leaked all over in both forward and retract. worst case it will begin spraying it out. spring return not so bad but a cylinder that is double acting is pressurized in both directions independtantly . in the extend mode the piston is pressurized from behind- but you have a cylinder of fluid ahead of it. in retract you are pressurizing the head area of the piston forcing the fluid behind the cylinder out, this where there most leakage will be observed in a full cycle from the ram / cylinder seal as you appling apx 600-900 psi. Dosen't take long to abraid a ram/cylinder seal with a pitted ram. Hydro fluid ain't cheap.